Opinion: Bonza’s here for the long haul
Don’t let teething problems fool you, the point-to-point carrier isn’t in retreat
The surprise last month wasn’t that Bonza, the low-cost carrier whose point-to-point service model had set tongues wagging all over the Australian aviation landscape, was cutting five routes – it’s that it cut them so soon.
Bonza had only seen wheels go up on its maiden flight in January, and yet come July it was already axing its services from Sunshine Coast to Coffs Harbour, Sunshine Coast to Port Macquarie, Sunshine Coast to Tamworth, Cairns to Mackay, and Toowoomba to Whitsunday Coast. The Sunshine Coast to Tamworth route, in particular, only launched on 6 May.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
The reasons? Something of a perfect storm of bad luck: Bonza’s fleet of four 737 MAX 8 aircraft were struggling to keep up with demand on the initial 27-route network, especially when combined with mechanical issues and an unfortunate spate of birdstrikes.
This had a knock-on effect for pilot training, as well – given that pilots needed instruction in the aircraft themselves, when the planes were out of commission, the pilots couldn’t be trained. While Bonza is anticipating a fifth 737 MAX 8, that’s not expected until closer to the end of the year.
“When we look at that demand, when we look at the converse of really strong demand on other routes, and we see the reality of some of our reliability challenges and know that we need to solve for that within our four aircraft, it really just accelerates something that likely may not have changed, but is a decision we’ve taken a bit sooner than we would have expected we’d need to,” Bonza chief customer officer Carly Povey told Australian Aviation at the time.
This, coupled with the fact that another of the routes, Sunshine Coast to Coffs Harbour, is one that had been publicly mocked by Rex’s John Sharp as unviable, might lead the observer to think Bonza’s business model of flying point-to-point between largely regional and holiday destinations was flawed from the start.
But are they right?
Well, consider the following: at the same time as it was slashing five underperforming routes, Bonza was also adding capacity on three routes that had proven to perform very well, namely Sunshine Coast to Albury, Sunshine Coast to Avalon, and Melbourne to Port Macquarie.
At the start of August, as well, Bonza unveiled its third base on the Gold Coast, with 11 new routes to existing destinations. Savvily, the carrier looks to be solving its small fleet problem by at least initially wet-leasing aircraft to operate from the new base while it awaits more of its signature purple-and-white MAX 8s.
Neither of these are the actions of an airline on the brink of collapse. Rather, they are the mark of a new airline finding its feet and seeing what works and what doesn’t. The point-to-point model is one that’s been common among regional and low-cost airlines in places like the US – think of carriers like Southwest and Spirit – and while the argument has long been that Australia is too small to justify this sort of operation, the counter-argument is: nobody’s tried before, so how do we know?
Remember, before Bonza, nobody at all was flying between Melbourne and Port Macquarie, or Albury and the Sunshine Coast. If nobody had tried, then nobody would have found out that the routes work, and work well enough to justify increasing their capacity.
As Bonza CEO Tim Jordan told this publication earlier this year: “Since Compass Airlines, the population of Australia has increased by 50 per cent. Since Virgin Blue launched 21 years ago, the population of Australia has increased by more than a third. That lends itself to exactly what we’re doing. We have a large degree of confidence in our actions.”
Another salient point Jordan raised is that re-evaluating and cutting routes that weren’t working was always the plan, even if nobody was expecting Bonza to do it quite so soon.
“One of the things that infuriates me about this wonderful industry is we probably need to take advantage that our factory moves. If you’re in manufacturing and put a factory in a location, you’re stuck there. Our factories move, so if something’s not working, let’s move it. Let’s move our capacity somewhere else,” he said.
“We don’t do that readily enough or quickly enough as an industry. The vast majority of what we put out there will work. Some of it may not. But we will learn from that. And we will learn quite quickly, and we will change it if necessary.”
By redeploying its existing aircraft to higher-performing routes and reaching out to wet-lease operators for new services, Bonza is taking steps to add what its business model had thus far lacked: resilience. Here’s hoping that will see our newest low-cost airline criss-crossing “Allstralia’s” skies for a long time yet.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.