Close sidebar

WA opts out of plan to open borders by Christmas

written by Adam Thorn | September 4, 2020
Qantas Boeing 737-800 VH-VXM featuring the new livery at Perth Airport. (Dylan Thomas)
Qantas Boeing 737-800 VH-VXM featuring the new livery at Perth Airport. (Dylan Thomas)

A plan to open all borders in Australia by Christmas has been agreed by all states and territories – except Western Australia.

However, Prime Minister Scott Morrison said that all states had agreed to a definition of what constitutes of a COVID-19 “hotspot”, which would be used to guide future closures.

Speaking after a meeting of the country’s national cabinet, Prime Minister Morrison pointedly refused to criticise the decision of WA Premier Mark McGowan.

Advertisement
Advertisement

“Western Australia has a very different border and a very different economy than most of the other states and territories where these decisions have been made,” he said.

“Not everyone has to get on the bus for the bus to leave the station. But it is important the bus leaves the station.”

The proposed definition of a hotspot for metropolitan areas would be a rolling three-day average of 10 locally acquired cases per day, compared with just three cases in rural areas.

There is currently no definition of how big a “metropolitan area” would be or exactly what that would constitute.

PROMOTED CONTENT

NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian argued her state would therefore have no areas deemed a hotspot if the rules were enforced today.

“If you look at the specific definition which national cabinet is considering, at this point in time, there wouldn’t be anywhere in NSW as of today that would be defined as a formal hotspot,” Premier Berejiklian said.

“There shouldn’t be an excuse for any state to have a border that isn’t open with NSW.

“If the trends continue the way they are, I don’t think any state border should exist by Christmas – unless Victoria flares up again, which I hope it won’t.

“Even though some states are not as comfortable as others, I’m hopeful that, by Christmas, Australia will be a different place.”

Her comments are significant given many states have shut off to NSW, including most notably Queensland.

The positive development comes after Qantas chief executive Alan Joyce accused Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk of closing her borders purely for political gain.

He said the restrictions, which include shutting off NSW and the ACT, will cause a lot of small companies in Queensland “to go out of business”, adding that states had no excuse not to open up to areas with few coronavirus cases.

“Surely these decisions should be based on the facts and the level of cases that we’re seeing around the various states?” said Joyce.

Later, the head of Qantas’ pilots’ association echoed Joyce’s calls for a national consensus on state border closures.

Mark Sedgwick, the executive director of the Australian and International Pilots Association (AIPA), also told this week’s Australian Aviation podcast he thinks border closures can’t eradicate COVID-19 altogether.

Fly into Spring with Australian Aviation’s latest print edition. Starting from $49.95 a year, you can read comprehensive coverage on all sectors of the industry to keep you in the loop. Get your hands on the subscription today. Subscribe now at australianaviation.com.au.

4 Comments

  • Dave

    says:

    There is no logical nor health related reason why WA shouldn’t be open to SA, NT, QLD and TAS. McGowan doesn’t have any right to keep the hard border (aside from Vic and perhaps NSW), he doesn’t have a mandate to secede! He is costing jobs and economic benefits by not opening to half of the country. Now he doesnt even want to participate in defining a hotspot. Get real.

  • MikeofPerth

    says:

    Read the PM’s and Premier’s comments again Dave. There is greater economic benefit to WA and Australia by closing our borders for now than opening.

    Our situation is different here. We have no border communities and we are less economically integrated than the other states. We are within our rights.

    This isn’t about secession. It’s not like people from the east all have their bags packed, eager to come here for a holiday at the moment anyway.

  • Ron Hunter

    says:

    Time to get rid of States or enforce the No barriers to interstate commerce contained in the constitution.
    Migrant

  • MikeofPerth

    says:

    Get rid of the states Ron? Who would be the primary benefactors of that, NSW and VIC? 4 out of 6 states are required to get a majority on such a constitutional ammendment.

    Highly unlikely at least 4 would agree to that in the foreseeable future. We are going to have to live with being one of 25 federations in the world for now. Seems to be working very well from my perspective.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WA opts out of plan to open borders by Christmas

written by Adam Thorn | September 4, 2020
Qantas Boeing 737-800 VH-VXM featuring the new livery at Perth Airport. (Dylan Thomas)
Qantas Boeing 737-800 VH-VXM featuring the new livery at Perth Airport. (Dylan Thomas)

A plan to open all borders in Australia by Christmas has been agreed by all states and territories – except Western Australia.

However, Prime Minister Scott Morrison said that all states had agreed to a definition of what constitutes of a COVID-19 “hotspot”, which would be used to guide future closures.

Speaking after a meeting of the country’s national cabinet, Prime Minister Morrison pointedly refused to criticise the decision of WA Premier Mark McGowan.

Advertisement
Advertisement

“Western Australia has a very different border and a very different economy than most of the other states and territories where these decisions have been made,” he said.

“Not everyone has to get on the bus for the bus to leave the station. But it is important the bus leaves the station.”

The proposed definition of a hotspot for metropolitan areas would be a rolling three-day average of 10 locally acquired cases per day, compared with just three cases in rural areas.

There is currently no definition of how big a “metropolitan area” would be or exactly what that would constitute.

PROMOTED CONTENT

NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian argued her state would therefore have no areas deemed a hotspot if the rules were enforced today.

“If you look at the specific definition which national cabinet is considering, at this point in time, there wouldn’t be anywhere in NSW as of today that would be defined as a formal hotspot,” Premier Berejiklian said.

“There shouldn’t be an excuse for any state to have a border that isn’t open with NSW.

“If the trends continue the way they are, I don’t think any state border should exist by Christmas – unless Victoria flares up again, which I hope it won’t.

“Even though some states are not as comfortable as others, I’m hopeful that, by Christmas, Australia will be a different place.”

Her comments are significant given many states have shut off to NSW, including most notably Queensland.

The positive development comes after Qantas chief executive Alan Joyce accused Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk of closing her borders purely for political gain.

He said the restrictions, which include shutting off NSW and the ACT, will cause a lot of small companies in Queensland “to go out of business”, adding that states had no excuse not to open up to areas with few coronavirus cases.

“Surely these decisions should be based on the facts and the level of cases that we’re seeing around the various states?” said Joyce.

Later, the head of Qantas’ pilots’ association echoed Joyce’s calls for a national consensus on state border closures.

Mark Sedgwick, the executive director of the Australian and International Pilots Association (AIPA), also told this week’s Australian Aviation podcast he thinks border closures can’t eradicate COVID-19 altogether.

Fly into Spring with Australian Aviation’s latest print edition. Starting from $49.95 a year, you can read comprehensive coverage on all sectors of the industry to keep you in the loop. Get your hands on the subscription today. Subscribe now at australianaviation.com.au.

4 Comments

  • Dave

    says:

    There is no logical nor health related reason why WA shouldn’t be open to SA, NT, QLD and TAS. McGowan doesn’t have any right to keep the hard border (aside from Vic and perhaps NSW), he doesn’t have a mandate to secede! He is costing jobs and economic benefits by not opening to half of the country. Now he doesnt even want to participate in defining a hotspot. Get real.

  • MikeofPerth

    says:

    Read the PM’s and Premier’s comments again Dave. There is greater economic benefit to WA and Australia by closing our borders for now than opening.

    Our situation is different here. We have no border communities and we are less economically integrated than the other states. We are within our rights.

    This isn’t about secession. It’s not like people from the east all have their bags packed, eager to come here for a holiday at the moment anyway.

  • Ron Hunter

    says:

    Time to get rid of States or enforce the No barriers to interstate commerce contained in the constitution.
    Migrant

  • MikeofPerth

    says:

    Get rid of the states Ron? Who would be the primary benefactors of that, NSW and VIC? 4 out of 6 states are required to get a majority on such a constitutional ammendment.

    Highly unlikely at least 4 would agree to that in the foreseeable future. We are going to have to live with being one of 25 federations in the world for now. Seems to be working very well from my perspective.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Each day, our subscribers are more informed with the right information.

SIGN UP to the Australian Aviation magazine for high-quality news and features for just $99.95 per year