Virgin Australia has described Qantas’s argument that its proposed codeshare with Cathay Pacific would not reduce competition in the Australia-Hong Kong market as simplistic and incorrect.
Qantas is seeking approval from Australia’s International Air Services Commission (IASC) to have Cathay Pacific add its CX airline code 35 Qantas-operated flights a week from Brisbane, Melbourne and Sydney to Hong Kong.
The Flying Kangaroohas argued the focus of the codeshare is on attracting connecting passengers, with the codeshare flights to be sold only as part of a through journey involving connections either beyond Hong Kong on Cathay Pacific to destinations in India, Sri Lanka and Vietnam, among other countries, or to other Australian domestic destinations from Brisbane, Melbourne and Sydney on Qantas.
The proposed codeshare has been opposed by Virgin Australia, which said in its latest submission to the IASC it firmly rejected Qantas’s assertion there would be no adverse impact on the competitive dynamics on point-to-point routes between Australia and Hong Kong.
“This simplistic view is incorrect and glosses over the complexities of route profitability,” the Virgin Australia submission dated March 28 and published on the IASC website said.
Virgin Australia argued that all airlines carried a mix of passengers on their Australia-Hong Kong services comprising local point-to-point passengers, connecting passengers from either Australian domestic or international points heading to Hong Kong, passengers travelling beyond Hong Kong on connecting flights, and finally passengers with connecting flights at both ends of the route.
As such, Virgin Australia said it was logical to expect that approval of Qantas’s application would lead to an increase in the volume of connecting traffic, due to Cathay Pacific being able to sell Qantas-operated flights under the codeshare agreement. This would lead to higher passenger load factors for Qantas’s flights between Australia and Hong Kong.
“With this increased load, Qantas will have a greater ability to adopt different strategies on pricing and inventory management in both the local point-to-point markets, as well as behind connections on domestic Australian routes,” Virgin Australia said.
“To suggest otherwise would be completely contrary to established revenue management practices.
“The exclusion of point-to-point itineraries from Qantas’ application does not alter the fact that it still encompasses a code share on overlapping routes. This entails potentially significant detrimental impacts on competition.”
Qantas had told the IASC in a previous submission an average of 27 per cent of its passengers flying from Brisbane, Melbourne and Sydney to Hong Kong, or vice versa, were connecting passengers. Further, Qantas submission said the figure for Virgin Australia was, on average, 21 per cent. A number for Cathay Pacific was not provided.
“The competitive dynamics on the point to point routes will be unchanged by the proposed variation,” Qantas said.
Virgin Australia said the IASC would need to determine if the “extremely limited public benefits” associated with the proposed codeshare outweighed the “corresponding potential detriment to competition, tourism and trade”.
“From a practical perspective, Virgin Australia would encourage the Commission to consider whether a reasonable member of the travelling public, or an Australian exporter, would be willing to risk the Hong Kong route returning to a market dominated by two carriers in a duopoly, in exchange for gaining the ability to access marginal improvements in flight connection times and increased frequent flyer points,” Virgin Australia said.
“It is also important to note that the majority of passengers travelling on the Hong Kong route are travelling on point-to-point itineraries and it is therefore logical to expect that these travellers would consider that the benefits of robust competition from three or more carriers, in terms of lower airfares and increased service options, are more valuable than the claimed benefits of Qantas’ proposal.”
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has also raised concerns about the proposed Cathay Pacific and Qantas codeshare, with its submission to the IASC saying “the conduct may soften competition in the Australia-Hong Kong air passengers services market”.
Qantas also planned to add its QF airline code on 35 Cathay Pacific-operated flights a week from the same three Australian cities and Hong Kong.
While this did not require regulatory approval, Qantas has said previously “it should not be assumed” that the airline would still be able to codeshare on Cathay Pacific’s Australia-Hong Kong services should the IASC reject its application.
Instead, the ability for Qantas to codeshare on Cathay Pacific’s flights to Hong Kong from Brisbane, Melbourne and Sydney would be “placed at risk and subject to further discussions between the carriers”.
Cathay Pacific, Qantas and Virgin Australia the only three airlines with nonstop Australia-Hong Kong flights
Currently, Cathay Pacific serves six destinations in Australia – Adelaide, Brisbane, Cairns, Melbourne, Perth and Sydney – from its Hong Kong hub with a mix of Airbus A330-300s, A350-900s and Boeing 777-300ERs offering business, premium economy and economy. This does not include freighter services.
It is the only Hong Kong-based carrier offering nonstop flights to Australia, after Virgin Australia alliance partner Hong Kong Airlines withdrew its flights to Cairns and the Gold Coast in October 2018.
Qantas offers nonstop flights from Brisbane, Melbourne and Sydney to Hong Kong with a mix of Airbus A330s, A380s and Boeing 747s and 787-9s.
Virgin Australia started serving the Special Administrative Region (SAR) with its own aircraft in July 2017, when it began nonstop flights on the Melbourne-Hong Kong route with two-class Airbus A330-200s featuring 20 business class seats in a 1-2-1 configuration with direct aisle access for each passenger and 255 economy class seats at eight abreast.
It added daily Sydney-Hong Kong services, again with A330-200 equipment, in July 2018.