Virgin is adopting the B/E Aerospace Super Diamond design
The battle for business
It’s not too soon to call Virgin Australia the winner
With Virgin Australia’s selection of the B/E Aerospace Super Diamond business class seat – a fully flat bed with direct aisle access in a reverse herringbone configuration that’s up there with Zodiac’s very similar Cirrus seat for the title of best business class in the sky – the die has been cast in Australia’s business class game of oneupmanship.
Qantas’s next generation seat is the Thompson Vantage XL product, also a fully flat bed with direct aisle access, but arranged in a staggered layout with all seats parallel to the aircraft’s centreline.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
Thompson Vantage XL.
Longtime design collaborator Marc Newson is customising the base product for Qantas, and the design language is Newson’s signature blend of stylish and efficient.
Virgin’s seat is to be installed across its long-haul Boeing 777‑300ER and Airbus A330-200 fleet, giving product consistency on all widebody flights. Qantas’s seat is currently planned only for its A330 fleet, which means the domestic and regional A330 aircraft will surpass the A380 and refurbished 747-400 fleets in passenger experience.
We’ll see more of the bells and whistles on Qantas’s and Virgin’s seats as they make their way to aircraft starting at the end of this year.
But in terms of seat-to-seat comparison, it’s not too soon to call Virgin Australia the winner. The fact is that the design of Virgin’s seat is inherently superior to Qantas’s for at least half of the passengers in the cabin, and its equal for the rest. It’s down to the reverse herringbone configuration Virgin chose versus the staggered layout Qantas picked.
Original herringbone seats, designed by Virgin Atlantic 11 years ago, faced into the aisle. Reverse herringbone, introduced by US Airways in 2009, face towards the windows or the centreline of the aircraft – preferable for passengers, who can look out the window or converse with their middle seat neighbour, rather than pointing into the aisle.
Crucially, this is a layout where every seat is the same as the one in front of or behind it. Not so with Qantas’s product.
The staggered configuration, which Thompson initially created with its regular Vantage product, now upsized with the larger Vantage XL, has each seat offset from the next by half a seat-length. One passenger’s feet slide into an enclosed shell positioned next to the passenger in front, which also serves as the side table for that passenger. The pattern repeats every two rows.
The layout creates three types of seat within the cabin: half are “aisleaisle” seats directly next to the aisle, and the other half split between “window-aisle” or “centre-aisle” seats that have a foot shell side table between them and the aisle.
In front of each aisle-aisle seat’s foot shell is a small gangway forwindow-aisle and centre-aisle passengers to reach their seats without needing to disturb the aisle-aisle passenger.
As a result, aisle-aisle seats, which make up 50 per cent of the seats in the cabin, are fundamentally less private and markedly less desirable than the window-aisle or centre-aisle seats.
While window-aisle and centre-aisle passengers have about half a metre of side table between them and any fellow passenger or crew member walking down the aisle, that’s not so for anyone sitting in an aisle-aisle seat.
Qantas’s use of the Vantage XL is unlikely to resolve this, given that it eschews a Skybed-style wraparound protective shell for the passenger’s head in favour of an armrest-level half-shell that extends only 20-30cm above bed level. With a gap of roughly the same amount until the bottom edge of the side-only shell that’s at eye level when seated, the design risks passengers being disturbed when sleeping.
Beware hands and elbows slipping off the bed surface when asleep, too, lest they be banged into – and even in seat mode there’s nothing between an armrest-leaning elbow and a passing rollaboard bag or catering trolley.
Moreover, aisle-aisle seats’ lack of privacy is markedly at odds with what’s provided to window-aisle and even centre-aisle passengers.
They get extra privacy thanks to a unique-to-Qantas magazine or laptop storage box that also serves as a high barrier stretching a third of the bed’s entire length on the outside end of the side table. (If this barrier is installed on aisle-aisle seats, it will also block at least one and probably two windows from view. ) The window-aisle seats – a quarter of the “window seats” in the cabin – will be excellent as a result: private and undisturbed. The centre-aisle seats will come a second best for any solo traveller, yet the aisle-aisle seats will rank a distant third.
It’s hard to see how having so many of the seats in a brand new business class cabin clearly worse than the rest is a smart move for Qantas in the age where passengers have more access than ever before to knowledge about seating products, and are more vocal than ever about their preferences and experiences.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.