Opinion: Slot change now not such a gamble
In 2021 Rex was fighting a lonely battle to change airport rules, but now the tide appears to be turning
Two years ago, John Sharp, the deputy chairman of Rex, gave a speech at the CAPA aviation conference in Sydney where he spoke on the then-rarely discussed topic of airport take-off slots. Given its – shall we be frank – rather dull technicalities, Sharp sprinkled his words with his usual sense of mischief and razzamatazz.
“I want to talk to you,” he began, “a little bit about one of the barriers that we face – and anyone else who wants to grow the airline business in Australia faces – and that’s the restrictions that apply to Sydney Airport. They were not caused by Sydney Airport. They were caused by” – he paused for effect – “um… me, many years ago in another life when I put a cap of movements to Sydney Airport at 80 movements per hour. And to make that function, we tried a thing called the slot system.”
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
As you may be aware, the slot he was referring to is a literal take-off time slot at an airport. And because two aircraft can’t take off on the same runway simultaneously, competition is rife to secure the most lucrative times. Sharp’s system for divvying them out, devised when he was transport minister, aims to both increase competition and give airlines wriggle room to cancel flights for legitimate safety reasons.
The ‘80-20 rule’ says that an airline can keep a slot indefinitely so long as it flies that slot 80 per cent of the time. But that, for those paying attention at the back, means they can also cancel a flight one-fifth of the time and keep that plum service indefinitely, forever blocking out the competition.
“I will give you an example of what’s wrong with our current slot system at Sydney Airport,” he added, warming to his theme. “Virgin is a good example. Pity Jayne [Hrdlicka, its CEO] isn’t here, so she could boo at this point! Virgin pre-COVID had 173 aircraft in its fleet. After administration, they had 58 aircraft. That’s a 56 per cent reduction. And now they’ve gone from that number to the 68 aircraft Jayne mentioned a few moments ago, but that’s still a 49 per cent reduction in their numbers pre-COVID. And yet today, Virgin has more slots in Sydney Airport than before but half the number of aircraft. Virgin is sitting on slots and holding them, knowing that they will not use them, but they’ll keep holding onto them until the government changes the way things work.”
Back then, Sharp was fighting a lonely battle trying to convince the world that major airlines were gaming the system in a variety of ways to hoard the best slots. But with the emergence of another upstart rival in Bonza, his views are gaining major traction – not just on the online pages of Australian Aviation but major mass media, too. His campaign received quite the boost when the ACCC, choosing its words carefully, broke cover in June to say major airlines “can exploit” the system to block out smaller rivals.
The watchdog went even further, arguing that the system allowed airlines to “hoard” slots for “strategic reasons”. “Rex’s ability to continue to expand its intercity jet operations and bring choice and competition to more consumers each week will likely be hindered without better access to peak period slots at Sydney Airport,” it concluded.
And so, two years on, Sharp’s speech appeared to be justified. The intervention caused something of a chain reaction, with Bonza calling access to Sydney Airport the “biggest singular issue” in aviation before Sydney Airport itself called on the rules to be changed.
Yet, while Sharp may have built up a mountain of steam, he faces strong opposition to force a change to the 80-20 rule. In the weeks before this magazine went to press, both Qantas and Virgin have strongly denied any shenanigans. The Flying Kangaroo’s domestic CEO, Andrew David, didn’t hold back at Sydney Airport, telling it not to “demonise” its biggest client. In a stroppy press release, the business then said that it was “simply wrong” to suggest it was doing anything dodgy.
Where does this end? Well, the problem of access to Sydney slots will be naturally fixed when the new Western Sydney Airport opens, increasing capacity, but staggered start means it’s unlikely to make much difference to Rex and Bonza until at least the end of the decade. All of which would be too late as the two upstarts look to eat into Virgin and Qantas’s revenue.
Sharp, then, has to hope his pressure can force the government to act, but as yet there seems little appetite for forcing the policy change up the priority chain. What we can say is that in 2023 everyone in the industry is talking about slots. And the odds of changing the system have, at least, shortened.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.