Warts And All
As the US Air Force prepares for initial operational capability with the F-35A later this year, progress on the Joint Strike Fighter development program continues to attract scrutiny.
It’s my pink body on the line at the end of the day,” says Squadron Leader Andrew Jackson, Australia’s first F-35 pilot, on the capabilities of the RAAF’s next fast jet.
“It’s not without its warts but we know what they are and we are working to solve those,” SQNLDR Jackson, who is an instructor pilot on the F-35 with the US Air Force’s 56th Fighter Wing at Luke Air Force Base, Arizona told reporters during a media briefing in Canberra in early April.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
“Over the 12 months that I have been flying the aircraft there has been continual development. In terms of limitations that the aircraft was subject to when I first started flying it the aircraft had a subsonic limitation on it, so 0. 9 Mach, had a G restriction at the time of 3G and we’re now out to 7G, we’re out to unrestricted angle of attack, we’re up to Mach 1. 6. So in the space of 12 months there has been a lot of development. So my impression of the aircraft continues to change as we’re able to explore the flight envelope. ” “Broadly [I have] a very positive impression of the aeroplane. ” “I think the capability of the aeroplane is apparent to me and the fact that we know what the issues are and we are working towards [fixing them] suggests to me that it is going to be fine. ” That’s a perspective shared by his boss, Chief of Air Force Air Marshal Leo Davies.
“I have absolutely no reservations, zero reservations, about the decision for Joint Strike Fighter being the classic Hornet replacement for Australia,” CAF said during the RAAF’s Air Power Conference in late March.
“I do have some elements of the program that we need to keep an eye on, they need to mature yet.
near Luke AFB. usaf via defence
“There are proper questions about understanding its maturity; I think it’s a very fair question to ask, do we think we understand the aeroplane well enough to give guarantees to government and the Australian people that it is the right aeroplane?” he said.
But F-35 development issues aside, Australia’s F-35 project faces challenges in delivering facilities in a timely fashion and establishing the sustainment capability and Australian training system, as the RAAF prepares for the aircraft to reach initial operational capability (IOC) at the end of 2020.
The first two Australian F-35 aircraft, currently operating at Luke Air Force Base, were delivered in late 2014; the next eight will be delivered in 2018, with two of those aircraft to be ferried to Australia late that year. Another eight are scheduled for delivery in 2019, followed by 15 each year in 2020, 2021 and 2022, and then nine more in 2023 to make a total of 72.
In turn the ‘classic’ Hornet is set to be progressively withdrawn from service between 2018 and 2022.
That schedule for establishing the required support in time for the arrival at RAAF Base Williamtown of an initial two aircraft in December 2018 is “challenging”, as Defence acknowledges in a written submission to the Senate inquiry into the F-35 acquisition that is due to report by June 29.
Schedule pressures
The Integrated Investment Program that was published with the Defence White Paper refers to the project as ‘F-35A Joint Strike Fighter (JSF) Acquisition Stage One (72 aircraft)’ and lists it as being part of the ‘Strike and air combat’ capability stream, with the approximate investment value (acquisition only) quoted as $15. 3 billion.
Through-life sustainment costs are currently estimated to be $43 billion. An operating and support budget of $4. 6 billion out to 2024-25 was approved by the government in 2014, but these costs are expected to be refined in 2020 once F-35 global support arrangements have matured.
The separate approved project under which facilities are being provided in support of the F-35 at RAAF Base Williamtown in New South Wales and RAAF Base Tindal in the Northern Territory has a total estimated cost of $1. 48 billion.
The Defence Portfolio Additional Estimates Statements 2015-16 (PAES) warns that delivery of key infrastructure in a timely manner at both Williamtown and Tindal remains “high risk”, while noting that the risk profile of the F-35 project overall remains largely unchanged.
“The potential for the RAAF Base Williamtown groundwater contamination issue to impact facilities delivery [is] an emerging risk, which is being managed,” the PAES states in a project performance update.
And, echoing the PAES, the 2014-15 ANAO Major Projects Report states that while the delivery strategy for and scope of the facilities effort has been “significantly revised such that cost pressures are no longer considered a major threat to project success. . . schedule pressures are still a significant concern” in terms of establishing the facilities and information and communications technology (ICT) infrastructure required to support the introduction of the F-35.
As the Integrated Investment Program outlines, new and upgraded facilities and infrastructure to support the F-35 are set to be established between now and 2025-26, not only at Williamtown and Tindal, but also at Darwin, NT; Townsville and Scherger in Queensland; Pearce, Curtin and Learmonth in Western Australia; and Edinburgh in South Australia.
Enabling systems
The F-35 program is the largest project by total approved budget that is reviewed by the ANAO in the Major Projects Report that was tabled in January this year.
“The Australian F-35 program is making positive progress within the approved acquisition budget agreed by government, and is on schedule to achieve initial operating capability by December 2020,” a Defence spokesperson told sister magazine Australian Defence Business Review. The 2014-15 Major Projects Report’s project data summary sheet covering the F-35 acquisition, which was prepared by Defence, makes clear that the project is expected to deliver its materiel requirements, but notes that there are a number of risks to achieving some of the capabilities required for the declaration of IOC in December 2020 and final operational capability (FOC) in December 2023.
These risks include: the integration of the F-35 into the ADF, final software builds meeting required functionality in time for the IOC and FOC project milestones, establishing the sustainment capability and setting up the training system.
“The capability of the F-35A JSF air system is now reaching a level of maturity where the project is confident it will be able to meet the agreed threshold level of capability required for IOC in 2020,” states the project data summary sheet, reviewing its materiel capability delivery performance.
“However, there remain risks to achieving IOC and FOC of the JSF capability associated with establishment of enabling systems and capabilities, and risk to achieving FOC software capability on schedule. The enabling systems and capabilities include: sustainment establishment, facilities, information systems, reprogramming, weapons integration and training systems. ” The report identifies “significant workforce challenges in effectively manning the Defence acquisition and sustainment organisations” that it says are affecting program management activities as being a risk that emerged during 2014-15, with “supplemental resources” being provided in an effort to remedy the situation.
“The F-35 program is about to ramp up production numbers while also developing and maturing the F-35 global support system. The design of the Joint Strike Fighter Division workforce needs to evolve to address the complexity, size and scope of the program, including its global nature,” the Defence spokesperson explained to Australian Defence Business Review.
Management of the Australian F-35 program is now the responsibility of Air Vice-Marshal Leigh Gordon, who was appointed as Head Joint Strike Fighter within the Capability Acquisition and Sustainment Group (CASG) in March. He replaced the now-retired Air Vice-Marshal Chris Deeble, who has joined Airservices Australia to manage the OneSKY program.
The spokesperson for Defence continued: “F-35 training for Australian pilots and maintainers is under way in the United States in preparation for the arrival of Australia’s first two F-35 aircraft at the end of 2018. Training Australians in F-35 operations is of paramount importance to the successful transition into the Australian Defence environment.
“Maintenance training will start in Australia at the Integrated Training Centre operated by 2 Operational Conversion Unit at RAAF Base Williamtown from early 2019. Pilot training will start at 2 Operational Conversion Unit in 2020. Defence is working closely with the F-35 Joint Program Office and prime contractor Lockheed Martin to ensure training hardware and courseware delivery meets Australia’s requirements. ”
Block by block
The first operator to declare IOC with the F-35 was the US Marine Corps, which declared that its F-35B short takeoff/vertical landing (STOVL) variant had achieved that milestone in July last year, with a squadron of 10 aircraft with the Block 2B software configuration deemed to be ready for worldwide deployment.
There are a number of risks to achieving some of the capabilities required for IOC.
However, the FY2015 annual report from Dr J Michael Gilmore, the senior adviser to the US Secretary of Defense on operational test and evaluation, questioned this historic achievement.
“The program terminated Block 2B developmental flight testing in May 2015, delivering Block 2B capability with deficiencies and limited combat capability,” the Director, Operational Test & Evaluation (DOT&E) report states.
“The Marine Corps declared IOC at the end of July 2015; however, if used in combat, the Block 2B F-35 will need support from command-and-control elements to avoid threats, assist in target acquisition and control weapons employment for the limited weapons carriage available. ” Block 3i software was released for flight test in May 2015 to support the declaration of IOC by the US Air Force with the F-35A later this year, while coding for 3F, the final development software block, was completed in June 2015 and it too has been released for flight testing, the F-35 Joint Program Office (JPO) stated in its response to the report.
“Overall, the program is at a critical time,” Gilmore subsequently said in a statement to the US Congress’s House Armed Services Committee’s Tactical Air and Land Forces Subcommittee on March 23.
“Although the Marine Corps has declared initial operational capability (IOC) and the Air Force plans to do so later this calendar year (CY), the F-35 system remains immature and provides limited combat capability, with the officially planned start of Initial Operational Test and Evaluation (IOT&E) just over one year away. Over the past year, flight test teams continued to accomplish test flights at the planned rate, and a new version of software capability, Block 3i, was fielded.
“However, there are still many unresolved significant deficiencies, the program continues to fall behind the planned software block development and testing goals, and sustainment of the fielded aircraft is very burdensome,” Gilmore said.
“Right now the enterprise is focused on doing everything that is necessary on the industry side, to support the US Air Force being able to go to IOC sometime in the August or September timeframe of this year,” Lockheed Martin F-35 director of business development Steve Over told Australian Aviation in an interview on March 18. “We share the same view as Lt Gen Bogdan [Lt Gen Christopher Bogdan, the Program Executive Officer for the F-35 JPO] – the two biggest challenges for us, is 3i software, at a level of stability that the US Air Force is comfortable with, and getting ALIS (the Autonomic Logistics Information System) 2. 02 out there released in support of flying the airplanes.
“So on the software stability side, . . . 2B and early versions of 3i were more stable . . . than where we are right now. We understand what the issues are . . . it’s really a timing issue. We put the software on faster generation computers, and now we’re trying to work through some of the finesse and timing issues to get it where everything is all properly time sequenced. ” So what is the quantum of change from Block 3i to 3F? “It’s really not a quantum jump,” says Over. “It’s. . . more weapons [and] enhanced geolocation with fusion. So now we’re bringing in multi-ship operation. If you’ve ever seen me talk about the capability of the jet, I talk about how these aircraft hunt and fight as a pack of airplanes. It’s that pack mentality that’s really being finalised. ” The next eight aircraft for Australia will be built as part of Low Rate Initial Production (LRIP) batch 10 and will be delivered in 2018 with 3F software.
According to the JPO, Block 3F is due for completion towards the end of 2017, by the end of the System Development and Demonstration (SDD) phase that began back in 2001, in order to support IOC declaration for the US Navy with the F-35C carrier variant in 2018, and the start of Initial Operational Test and Evaluation (IOT&E).
definitive software standard. defence
But the DOT&E report states that the program will likely not finish Block 3F development and flight testing before January 2018, meaning that IOT&E, which involves operational test and evaluation to determine whether or not systems are operationally effective and suitable to support a full-rate production decision, would not begin earlier than August 2018.
“There were no surprises in the report; all of the issues mentioned are well known to the JPO, the US services, international partners and our industry team,” stated Lt Gen Bogdan, in the response dated January 29. “Although the DOT&E report is factually accurate, it does not fully address program efforts to resolve known technical challenges and schedule risks. ” Overall, the F-35 program is “executing fairly well across the entire spectrum of acquisition to include development and design, flight test, production, fielding, base stand-up, maintenance and support and building a global sustainment enterprise,” Lt Gen Bogdan later told the House Armed Services’ Tactical Air and Land Forces Subcommittee on March 22.
“The program is moving forward – sometimes slower than I’d like – but moving forward and making progress nonetheless. ”
By the numbers
“If you’re looking for statistics, to date of this multi-year SDD integration program, we’re about 82 per cent on the way through it. So, about 18 per cent left to go – approaching the end,” says Lockheed Martin’s Over.
On the software side, “It’s that integration and test activity,” says Over. “This is where we’re doing, what I would call varsity level tests. Where, you know, you’re putting up four F-35s; cooperative target aircraft; tankers; ground control; and we’re doing these really intense fusion level things. ”
These aircraft hunt and fight as a pack of airplanes. STEVE OVER
Remaining flight testing, or ‘flight sciences’, meanwhile is focused on “principally clearing the envelope and weapons integration on the aircraft,” Over says. “So, right now, even though the full envelope won’t be released to the operational fleet until 3F is out there, we’ve flown to all the corners of the envelope, and most of that testing is complete. And what we’re doing now, is mostly certifying the external storage that will be carried on the aircraft. ” From the Australian perspective, aircraft software is not considered to be a problem, at least in terms of the RAAF’s intended IOC/FOC timetable, as the Chief of Air Force stated when he addressed a media roundtable in February.
“On the trajectory we have for software development, for the mission data set that goes into our aircraft, we are on time for that to be delivered for our aircraft,” AIRMSHL Davies noted.
Not surprisingly, the maturity of the F-35 program and fleet at the time of RAAF service entry is a point stressed by Lockheed Martin’s Over.
“By the end of this year, more than 200 airplanes will be in operational service. Last year we delivered 45 aircraft; this year we’ll deliver 53,” Over says.
“Fast forwarding to 2018 and 2020, more than 340 airplanes by the end of 2018, when your first two airplanes come home. And when you stand up to IOC in 2020, more than 600 airplanes [will be] in the worldwide fleet. The numbers are growing significantly. ” As the fleet grows and production rates rise that has a promised positive effect on F-35 unit cost.
“I expect the cost of an F-35 with an engine to decrease from about [US]$108 million this year to about [US]$85 million in 2019,” Lt Gen Bogdan told the Congress subcommittee.
Biggest concerns
As the JPO acknowledged in its response to the DOT&E report, mission systems software and ALIS, which serves as the information infrastructure for the F-35, remain the program’s main technical risks.
“On the ALIS 2. 02 side. . . it’s a big capability leap,” says Over. “Up until 2. 02 we’ve had ALIS that supports the airplane mission systems; pilot flight planning; parts ordering, all that stuff. And then, Pratt & Whitney had a separate IT system that supported parts for the engine. 2. 02 merges those two together. And, like . . . Lt Gen Bogdan would tell you . . . we were probably four to six weeks behind. We’re putting resources on it because we want to recover that; we don’t want to be four to six weeks behind. We want to make sure we’ve done our part to support IOC by 1 August. ” Back in February AIRMSHL Davies specifically identified ALIS when asked about any concerns he might have about the JSF program from the Australian point of view.
“ALIS itself, the autonomic logistics; and indeed the foundation for ALIS to work, not as a software program, not as ones or zeros, but how do we as JSF international operators go about producing parts, distributing parts, warehousing, fitment? That whole piece, yet, is still maturing,” he said.
ALIS is designed to be capable of transmitting aircraft health and maintenance action information through a globally distributed network to technicians around the world.
“I think there is a little bit of letting go of sovereignty,” CAF continued. “We will need to be able to maintain, that is flightline maintain the aeroplanes. We will need to be able to have spares and warehousing and logistics to support it. We will need to be able to have weapons usage, and training and exercise, here in Australia. And if we accomplish that sovereign piece I am okay.
“We are experiencing it already through the C-17. This is really our first big move into a global supply chain, where we are part of the bigger outfit; JSF will be along the same lines.
“And I am not concerned about that at all, because we are going to have half the Western world relying on the Joint Strike Fighter as being serviceable and ready to fly. ”
Biggest potential
“What’s interesting, the Deputy Secretary of Defense, Bob Work, two weeks ago, spoke at a conference in the US; and he used a unique new phrase for the F-35. He called it the BN-35, the Battle Node 35. This is more than just a fighter. It’s something out there as a battle node in the warfare space,” Lockheed Martin’s Over said of the F-35’s potential.
And that potential is something that Australia gets.
“Australia is absolutely a thought leader in the F-35 universe,” said Over. “They’ve known for some time that this airplane has sensors like no other fighter in the world. ” But the challenge for Australia remains managing timeframes, not introducing the F-35 into RAAF service while it is still immature, and not waiting too long to replace the ageing classic Hornet.
“I think our timeline if I compare it to the USAF, US Marine Corps, US Navy from a delivery point of view and then an IOC/FOC point of view is good,” said SQNLDR Jackson. “We’ve got plenty of time. The USAF is going to go IOC later this year, we get to watch what occurs through their IOC process, what their learnings are. Navy is going to go IOC in 2019 before we do as well, so we get to learn a lot before we are actually in a position where we have to worry. So at the moment we are sitting back [able to] identify all the issues we need to consider before we start having to go through our own OT (operational test) processes here in Australia. I think our timeline is comfortable in that sense.
“Like always it will probably rear up upon us, but at the moment it is useful for us to sit back and follow the USAF. ”
I think there is a little bit of letting go of sovereignty. AIRMSHL DAVIES
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.