Three’s A Crowd?
Air New Zealand’s decision to look at dumping its stake in Virgin Australia may look like an aviation version of marital break-up but if their prime rival Qantas thinks it represents a serious rift between the two members of its major Australasian competition it should think again. Selling shares is a long way from abandoning commercial partnership agreements.
Airline boards and their chief executives are as pragmatic as they come. So it should be no surprise that Air NZ, currently pumping out record profit after record profit, should take a serious look at opting out of an investment that has never provided it with returns.
According to analysts at Deutsche Bank, the Kiwi flagship has poured some NZ$480 million into building up its stake in Virgin to 25. 9 per cent – some 914 million shares – since it first invested in 2011. And that doesn’t include another NZ$131. 2 million – Air NZ’s share of a NZ$470 million loan from it and fellow shareholders Singapore Airlines and Etihad Airways to give the carrier a 12-month emergency line of finance to shore up its financial position – announced just a week before Air NZ chief executive Christopher Luxon on March 30 told the world he was stepping down from the Virgin board with immediate effect. At the same time it was revealed First NZ Capital and Credit Suisse had been appointed to review its stake in the airline.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
It was the start of a rough period for Virgin. Ratings agency Standard & Poor’s the next day immediately revised its outlook on the airline to “negative” from “stable”, with analyst Graeme Ferguson citing “uncertainty over Virgin Australia’s near-term funding requirements and future ownership structure”.
A week later, Moody’s did the same, with its vice-president and senior analyst Ian Chitterer saying the review of Virgin’s credit rating reflected the agency’s concerns about the airline’s capital structure review and its level of shareholder support. “The review also reflects the slower-than-expected momentum now evident in the deleveraging of the business and the deterioration in its liquidity profile. ” These may be turbulent times for Virgin – which has returned to profitability though its returns have been well and truly eclipsed by the spectacular turnaround in income at Qantas – but for Air NZ this is no dramatic change in its strategy or direction.
The airline has not expanded on its statement to the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) on developments. In that statement Luxon did say: “We look forward to continuing our partnership on the Tasman alliance providing customers with the most comprehensive trans-Tasman network. ” That alliance offers customers on both Air NZ and Virgin more than 200 flights a week to more than 60 destinations across Australia and New Zealand, as well as flexible fares, reciprocal lounge access and frequent flyer benefits. While not due for renewal until October 2018, negotiations between the two carriers are expected to start in earnest next year.
In purely commercial terms it is highly doubtful either carrier will want to bring it to an end. Sources at the airline in Auckland confirmed to Australian Aviation the shareholding in Virgin is entirely separate from the trans-Tasman alliance and in terms of that agreement it is “business as usual”.
While Air NZ will certainly take a bath, losing cash if it sells its Virgin stake, it will be able to use however much money it does get in its own operations or to de-gear its balance sheet and improve its own financial position even further.
Veteran Air New Zealanders are also mindful of another fact: the disastrous investment the carrier had in Ansett Australia which in 2001 led to bankruptcy and a government bailout to save it from collapse. No-one wants a repeat of that.
Whether Luxon had, as several reports have suggested, been lobbying for Virgin chief executive John Borghetti to step down or not, it has become clear that Air NZ was not entirely happy with the Australian carrier’s performance. As long ago as February last year the Air NZ chief declared publicly it was time for Virgin “to get profitable”. It has. But not by enough to ease the concerns of one of its major shareholders. Highly profitable it may be but like all airlines, even with today’s low fuel costs, Air New Zealand needs a healthy balance sheet and cash in hand to deal with fierce competition in the marketplace. It has decided the money it can get from the sale of its Virgin shares can be far better employed elsewhere.
Neil Hansford, the chairman of aviation consultancy Strategic Aviation Solutions, told Australian Aviation he believed the proceeds could be used for further growth in its international business, a war chest for the battle against an expanding Qantas-owned Jetstar in its home New Zealand market, or a third idea that has been previously floated at times over the history of Air NZ – operating domestic routes within Australia.
The money it can get from the sale of its Virgin shares can be far better employed elsewhere.
Already in 2016 Air NZ is preparing to launch three new destinations in Asia – Ho Chi Minh City, Manila and Osaka – and is undertaking a significant revamp and capacity boost in its domestic operations.
And Luxon, above and beyond everything else, is a businessman who seeks and gets results. The former Unilever high-flyer, who became Air New Zealand’s chief executive in 2013, has used what he called his “Go Beyond” strategy to drive the Auckland-based carrier into a new era of profitability. His approach is all optimism. Unlike most of the rest of the world he doesn’t see New Zealand as being a remote land at the end of the line. He once said that as far as Air NZ was concerned, he didn’t see many challenges. “I just see a lot of opportunities…For us it’s a question of how fast we can secure them and get into them. ” He has always insisted that New Zealand is ideally placed to take full advantage of the fast-growing markets that stretch around the Pacific Rim. “Sitting in this Pacific Rim region, there are huge opportunities for us to offer the future massive middle class and rapidly urbanizing large countries around us a great tourism experience in New Zealand as the power moves from the Atlantic to the Pacific. ” He has driven growing revenues and profits through cost discipline, ensuring the carrier is customer-centric, generating good economic returns and being with the right partners, such as other Star Alliance members as well as non-alliance operators such as Virgin. That won’t change with his departure from the Virgin board and neither will Air NZ’s overall strategy. Neither will Virgin’s strategy.
For Virgin Australia also, if Air NZ offloads its shares, the shift will take place in the boardroom, not on the tarmac. Borghetti, who has received much praise for the remarkable job he has done turning the former budget Virgin Blue into the full-service Virgin Australia, clearly has much to worry about but he says he isn’t going anywhere.
In his only public comments since the Air NZ drama emerged Borghetti defended his turnaround strategy for the airline. “I don’t intend to go anywhere,” he told the Australian Financial Review.
“I’ve still got things I need to get done. . . There have been a lot of tough weeks. Whenever you are trying to create something worth fighting for you will have detractors trying to pull you down. This week is just one more week,” he said.
What he does need to do is show Virgin is making big strides in sorting out its cash situation. It recently revealed that its unrestricted cash balance had fallen by 24 per cent to A$544 million at December 31, compared with $719 million at June 30, which hurt the company’s liquidity and credit profiles. The airline is in the midst of a capital review aimed at focusing on how it can find new sources of funding to continue growing after an intense period of investment to transform its business to battle Qantas’s dominance of the corporate and business markets.
Deutsche Bank research analyst Cameron McDonald said he expected Virgin’s capital review to address three key areas – debt levels, hedging policies and implementation strategies.
On fuel, McDonald’s analysis found Virgin’s hedging policy “has left over $100 million on the table”, given the company has hedged its 2015/16 second half fuel bill at A$77 per barrel, with 14 per cent downside participation. This compared with an average fuel price of just under A$49 per barrel in the three months to March.
“The company is the best part of A$30/bbl out of the money and with a fuel burn of around 4. 5 million barrels per half year then that could mean the fuel bill is around $109 million higher than it could otherwise have been,” McDonald said in a research note dated April 11.
“Hence the hedging policy and the execution of the policy need to be reviewed. ” The capital review may also consider changes to Virgin’s frequent flyer program Velocity, which is 35 per cent owned by Affinity Equity Partners. McDonald noted Affinity, which paid $336 million for its Velocity stake in October 2014, will be able to sell its shareholding after the three-year anniversary of the sale in October 2017.
“Virgin has the first right of offer in relation to Affinity’s stake but can also participate in any other exit mechanisms that Affinity may pursue,” McDonald said.
“Virgin is going to have to consider as part of its capital review whether it intends to buy back the stake or whether it intends to sell down further in the event Affinity also sells. ”Moody’s Chitterer, meanwhile, made it clear what was necessary to achieve a ratings upgrade. “In order for the rating agency to consider an upgrade to B1, we would need to see strong shareholder support, operational initiatives to enhance cash flow and profitability, and debt reduction to a level well inside the thresholds for a B1 rating. The rating agency views this scenario as unlikely,” he said. And S&P said Virgin faced “a potentially sizable funding requirement over the next 12 months”.
However, Borghetti says he has largely achieved everything he set out to do and that he cannot understand the criticism at a time when the airline has returned to profitability.
“When we were losing $300 million no-one said so much as ‘boo’. And now we have posted the biggest profit in the front half since 2010 (Virgin posted a first-half profit of A$81. 5 million) and everyone is coming out of the woodwork. You kind of scratch your head a bit,” he commented.
“Ever since day one there have been people that have not believed we could achieve things. Analysts in particular because of their short-term thinking are focused on the next reporting period and we always said from the first day I walked in this is a long-term game. ” The primary question occupying analysts’ minds if Air NZ does pull out is: what then happens to Virgin’s shareholding? Not surprisingly, the pundits were quick to emerge, talking of a share buying battle between the two other major airline shareholders, Etihad Airways with 25. 1 per cent and Singapore Airlines with 23. 1 per cent (Sir Richard Branson’s Virgin group also holds 10 per cent with the remainder in the hands of smaller shareholders).
If either Etihad or SIA did attempt to buy up all of Air NZ’s stake it would effectively give the winner majority ownership of the airline, a move that would be subject to Foreign Investment Review Board approval. Many observers believe SIA is the most likely. Indeed, SIA made the first move, confirming on April 6 an increase in its Virgin stake from 22. 91 per cent to 23. 11 per cent. But whether SIA, which has FIRB approval to go up to 25. 9 per cent, would want to purchase all of Air NZ’s stake remains to be seen.
Deutsche Bank’s McDonald said SIA could be interested in a controlling stake if it could gain access to operating Virgin’s international routes, particularly flights across the Pacific.
“Singapore may see additional value in this which may impact the capital structure review that VAH is undertaking,” he said.
Meanwhile James Hogan, the Australian-born chief executive of Etihad, speaking at a Melbourne City Football Club lunch in his hometown, declared his airline was “a partner not a predator”. He said he was unable to comment on the Air NZ move because Etihad was a board member but was very positive about the Virgin partnership, saying he was “committed for the long-term”.
But the existing shareholders won’t be the only ones keeping an eye on developments. For example, Chinese airlines, deeply interested in the Australian market, have hinted before that they will look at investing in Australia. Delta Airlines, which has a trans-Pacific alliance with Virgin, may also be tempted. On the other hand, rather than fighting to become the biggest shareholder, SIA and Etihad could come to an arrangement to each take around half of Air NZ’s stake. And although unlikely, Sir Richard Branson may be tempted to take the roughly A$660 million he is expected to pocket from the sale of Virgin America to Alaska Airlines to boost his shareholding in the Australian carrier.
Whatever the outcome, it is not going to alter Borghetti’s position at Virgin. Luxon was only one member of the Board and it appears the majority who remain are solidly behind the current chief executive and his ongoing plans and strategies.
Additional reporting by Jordan Chong.
We always said from the first day I walked in this is a long-term game. JOHN BORGHETTI
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.