The charred remains of the Superjet 100 the day after the crash at Moscow’s Sheremetyevo International Airport. TWITTER/TASS
It’s an image problem
When tragedy grabs hold of the mainstream
It’s been a high-profile year for commercial airline operations and not necessarily for the right reasons. The Boeing 737 MAX tragedies have dominated the headlines, while the recent vision of the Aeroflot Sukhoi Superjet 100 (SSJ100) becoming a fireball has raised the conversation to fever pitch.
As always, the usual suspects have raised their heads across the board. Early, unfounded speculation and a social media feeding frenzy set the ball in motion. In the case of the Aeroflot accident, some passengers apparently still tried to evacuate with their hand luggage. In more recent discussion, pilot error and the erosion of manipulative skills has resurfaced.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
There are no surprises in this and anyone involved in aviation is becoming conditioned to the ongoing pattern. However, more worrying is the genuine concern being expressed in the broader community. Not since the disappearance of MH370 and, to a lesser extent, the shoot down of MH17 in relatively quick succession, has commercial airline tragedy broken through to mainline media in such a way. And in the case of the doomed Malaysian Airline’s flights, it was more an air of mystery and intrigue.
In the case of the MAX and the SSJ100, the public’s concern is more focused on the integral safety of air travel from the conversations taking place. That such a long-established airliner like the 737 could be fundamentally flawed has caught the eye and prompted debate about new technologies.
In the Russian accident, the sight of flames and billowing black smoke are eye-catching but more to the point, the misinterpretation is that a lightning strike equals a fireball. For those looking more closely at the footage, they are wondering about what sort of pilot can bounce an aeroplane until it breaks? We can all appreciate that there are still a lot of facts to be verified before the pieces of the puzzle can truly come together but the travelling public’s concern is immediate. And that is understandable.
In the case of Boeing, one can only imagine the hours and resources being poured into the MAX dilemma to not only rectify the fault but recover their reputation and lost ground. With the type grounded around the world, entire fleets are at a standstill and the future timeline for any return of the MAX could be described as cautiously optimistic at best.
Into the mix is that, even to its critics, commercial aviation is regarded as a very safe form of transport that has continually worked to be even safer, decade after decade. The statistics outweigh the anecdotes but even so, the reality of these tragedies inevitably causes ripples in confidence.
Those ripples can reach quite a way. It’s not only frequent flyers who have been asking questions of late but school teachers and parents whose children are contemplating a career in aviation. These people are in positions of influence where the next generation is concerned. If they are fortunate enough to speak with an informed aviation individual, common sense and rationale can return. However, if left to fester in a coffee shop conversation, such as I am currently witnessing, the misinformation is potentially one post or tweet away from reaching another hundred. Or more.
Every day, competent, well-trained crews safely transport millions of lives around the world. On those relatively rare occasions when an anomaly arises, most are countered without event by training, procedures and accumulated experience. However, these instances don’t grab the headlines. Occasionally they will surface through the release of an ATSB report or similar, but once again it is most likely that only those already in the industry will pay attention in a classic example of preaching to the converted.
Any aviation incident will probably continue be the proverbial media whipping boy. An uneventful ‘gear up’ landing of a Baron has always bumped a fatal car accident for the 30-second grab on prime-time TV. It’s a situation, no matter how unfair, that is just simply the way it is. As individuals, we can’t compete on a large scale against the internet’s reach but there’s no harm in reminding folks of the reality when their concerns are raised.
Furthermore, positive stories such as the evolution of biofuels in air transport, zero-waste flights and the positive actions of crew will rarely become a break-out story. It took Captain Chesley Sullenberger to have a dual engine failure and successfully conduct a landing on the icy Hudson River to bring a positive aviation outcome to the front page. We can’t all have that happen and I don’t think any of us want to try.
One hundred per cent safety is not achievable in any endeavour, although aviation still aspires to this goal and in most cases does an outstanding job. There is no denying that the industry has had its image tarnished by recent events, resulting in rising public concern. In a world where it seems to take a thousand positives to counter a single negative, commercial air transport has been in the cross-hairs.
All that we can do is continue to make our industry better at all levels. In this way, not only will the statistics improve but the counter arguments will become more prevalent. It may well be an argument that in the short term and on the surface can never be won but neither of those phrases are compatible with safety. Aviation is about deeply rooted positive cultures and long-term, ongoing improvement. It may not make the headlines but it is what allows us to go home at the end of the day.
‘It seems to take a thousand positives to counter a single negative’
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.