An Air India 787-8 departs Sydney Airport. (Image: Seth Jaworski)

Opinion: Enough armchair analysis, please

The ashes in Ahmedabad hadn’t even cooled before the internet and media started scrambling to advance theories and questions and rumours about the causes of the crash of Air India Flight 171, which killed 261 people in the first ever fatal hull loss of a 787 Dreamliner on 12 June.

Initially, of course, the speculation revolved mainly around the prospect of a mechanical failure. Boeing, the manufacturer of the 787-8 that crashed into a building seconds after take-off as the pilots struggled to gain altitude, has not exactly had the best reputation over the past few years. With the crashes of two 737 MAX 8 planes due to faulty software, the door plug blowing off a 737 MAX 9, and numerous accusations and whistleblower reports of lax safety standards at its manufacturing plants and external suppliers, the planemaker looked easy to blame.

This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
Login
Become a Member
To continue reading the rest of this article, please login.

or

To unlock all Australian Aviation magazine content and again unlimited access to our daily news and features, become a member today!
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
PRINT
$49.95 for 1 year Become a Member
See benefits
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
PRINT + DIGITAL
$99.95 for 1 year Become a Member
$179.95 for 2 years Become a Member
See benefits
  • Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
  • Access to the Australian Aviation app
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
  • Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
  • Daily news updates via our email bulletin
DIGITAL
$5.99 Monthly Become a Member
$59.95 Annual Become a Member
See benefits
  • Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
  • Access to the Australian Aviation app
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
  • Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
  • Daily news updates via our email bulletin

But as the rest of Air India’s 787 fleet got a clean bill of health and details of what happened in the cockpit started to emerge, the speculation began to take a less savoury direction. Why had the fuel switches to both engines been turned off, people asked, thus causing the lack of power that robbed the plane of life? Was it an accident, a problem with the switches themselves… or a deliberate action on the part of one of the pilots?

It was amidst this fevered finger-pointing that an email landed in our media inbox the other week from the 7NEWS Spotlight program. “PILOTS WHO KILL”, the media alert trumpeted, continuing in dire words to say that it was “becoming increasingly likely that the aircraft was deliberately crashed by one of its pilots”, pointing to “periods of depression” and “medical leave” reportedly taken by the flight’s captain, and raising the spectre of Germanwings 9525, which was deliberately flown into a mountain by its co-pilot in 2015 – including plonking family members of the Germanwings victims in front of the cameras to relive their trauma for the viewing public.

To this – and to the other media outlets all zeroing in on the captain as a potential perpetrator of a mass murder-suicide based on, at this point, mostly hearsay and conjecture – I can only ask: What is wrong with you?

For starters, who does this help, exactly? Certainly not the investigators, who are trying to do their jobs and identify the actual cause of the disaster – the US National Transportation Safety Board’s (NTSB) chair Jennifer Homendy, for example, has publicly decried the media frenzy around the crash as “premature and speculative”.

“India’s Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau just released its preliminary report. Investigations of this magnitude take time,” she stressed on social media.

The Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) itself, meanwhile, has gone further, reminding the world press that it is “too early to reach any definite conclusions” at this stage and that now is “not the time to create public anxiety or angst towards the safety of the Indian aviation industry, particularly on the basis of unfounded facts”.

“It is essential to respect the sensitivity of the loss faced by family members of deceased passengers, crew of the aircraft and other deceased persons on the ground,” the AAIB said. “It has come to our attention that certain sections of the international media are repeatedly attempting to draw conclusions through selective and unverified reporting. Such actions are irresponsible, especially while the investigation remains ongoing. We urge both the public and the media to refrain from spreading premature narratives that risk undermining the integrity of the investigative process.”

One of the key attributes of accident investigations, including the one being conducted by the AAIB at the moment and all those conducted by the Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB), is a “no-blame” process: rather than looking to find and punish someone for an accident, it simply looks to discover what happened so it can be prevented from happening again. This encourages people to speak more freely and share information that otherwise might be held back for fear of consequences, as the ATSB itself says on its website.

“The aim of all ATSB investigations is to prevent the occurrence of other accidents and incidents, rather than to assign blame or liability. This approach helps ensure the continued free flow of safety information for the purposes of improving safety in the future.”

Meanwhile, leaving aside the potential impact on the investigation: as the AAIB alluded to in its statement, what is this media circus doing to the victims’ families? If your loved ones were killed in a horrific crash, would you want the tabloid press all over the world bringing up the horror of your loss over and over again in a mad rush for clicks and eyeballs? And, for that matter, what of the pilot’s family and friends? How must they be feeling, with everyone and their cat wondering aloud if he deliberately killed more than 250 people? Maybe he did, maybe he didn’t – but if he didn’t, are outlets like Spotlight and that repeat offender the Daily Mail going to apologise?

(As an aside, while we may never find the truth of what happened there, this also goes for some of the more ghoulish documentaries on the disappearance of MH370. Enough is enough, please.)

We’re all guilty of armchair analysis – we all want to figure out what happened – but until the report is released and the truth finally comes out, for the sake of the victims, their families and the experts hard at work on finding out what happened, we should leave the investigations to the investigators. As aviation experts and journalists, the most honest answer – the only responsible answer – we should be giving to “why did this happen?” is, at least for right now, “we just don’t know”.

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.

You need to be a member to post comments. Become a member today!
Momentum Media Logo
Most Innovative Company
Copyright © 2007-2026 MOMENTUMMEDIA