Former Qantas CEO Alan Joyce speaks at the 2025 Australian Aviation Summit. (Image: Jake Nelson)
Opinion: Does Alan Joyce deserve a second chance?
And just like that, he was back.
Alan Joyce, the most famous (or infamous) figure in our sector, was the keynote speaker at our annual Australian Aviation Summit. If you were surprised to see him there, then, if I’m honest, we were, too. Next to nothing has been said by him since he stepped down as Qantas CEO more than two years ago, with the Australian public having decided that he was solely responsible for bringing their much-loved national carrier into disrepute. Since then, the Flying Kangaroo’s board has substantially reduced Joyce’s exit bonuses. Two biographies have painted a fairly damning portrait of his time in charge, while an investigation after his exit criticised his “command and control” leadership style.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
Joyce’s appearance came about when I was searching for speakers for the event and stumbled across a handful of websites seemingly offering his services for corporate shindigs. At the time, nobody had even reported he was available, and we promptly ran that as an exclusive on our website. When Will, our sales director, told me we should make an approach, I promptly told him we had no chance in hell of getting him to appear. Surely, I thought, he would choose an easier audience for his big return than a room full of industry insiders and professionals. Except what we didn’t realise is that Joyce himself was planning a comeback into aviation and wanted to use his speech to both defend his record and outline where he believed the future of aviation should be heading.
And so, in Sydney, a significantly trimmer and chirpier Alan Joyce bestrode onto the stage like he’d never been away. What he delivered, as my colleague Stephen Kuper writes in this issue, was closer to a manifesto than an address. A plea to both re-evaluate his time in charge, while also giving him a chance to have a career in the sector moving forward.
Qantas, he argued, remained the only major Australian airline not to fall into insolvency. “That wasn’t luck,” he thumped. “That was resilience.” And resilience, he continued, was a product of years of careful planning. “Resilience means preparing in the good times. Strengthening your balance sheet when the skies are clear. Investing in your fleet before the storm hits.”
Or in other words, Joyce had been prepping for COVID-19 all along. It sounds fanciful, but it’s also true that he has more of a point than many give him credit for. During the dark days of 2020, he routinely told the media that a crisis affects aviation every seven years, while senior figures at the airline whispered to me that Qantas had even created a pandemic action plan in advance, designed for just such a crisis. Don’t believe me? Well, Qantas was one of the first companies in Australia – and arguably the world – to begin to “stand down” employees – a term nobody had ever heard of weeks earlier.
But then, with a flourish, he pivoted to the future, presenting a roadmap akin to a politician addressing a rally. “The aviation industry has committed to net-zero by 2050,” he questioned. “But let’s not be naïve. Australia will fail to meet these goals without dramatically increasing the production and use of SAF. And right now, we are falling well short.” That was just the start of his warnings. The industry itself, he said, needed to stop worrying about AI taking jobs and start planning for a world where we don’t have enough humans to do the work. “By 2044, the global industry will need 660,000 new pilots, 710,000 maintenance technicians, and one million cabin crew,” he said. “Are we preparing young Australians for the jobs that will still exist, and will be growing?”
Joyce deserves to be listened to because, for all his apparent faults, he was never afraid to speak his mind when others shirked an issue. From his extraordinary rows with the transport unions – including the day he grounded the entire airline – to his infamous spats with Rex deputy chairman John Sharp – the propellers of his rivals, he chimed, were “practically falling off” – Joyce was never afraid to ruffle feathers.
His acid tongue, then, and no-nonsense approach were a key reason he became not just the most famous business leader in Australia, but one of the most famous figures in the country overall. Hell, he’s no Chris Hemsworth, but does anyone outside the sector really know the name of his successor? In reality, it’s not so much that history was unfairly unkind to his tenure but that, perhaps, history needs to judge him more on the context of the time he served.
It was Alan Joyce who steered Qantas through not just COVID, but the capacity wars with Virgin, the emergence of low-cost flying, a global financial crash and a collapse in supply chains. Qantas survived and became more profitable than ever, while many of its international rivals sank. He was also personally not the monster many make him out to be. I’ll never forget when my former colleague, Chris Fenton, then working as cabin crew at Jetstar, told me his former boss would help clean up aircraft after they landed, chipping in with the staff.
So, Joyce is back. A man with a plan – but without a job to enable him to set to work. Can he truly change popular opinion and secure his return? Well, if experience still counts for something – if hard lessons learned in crisis still matter – then his return to the stage shouldn’t be dismissed. Redemption is rarely neat, and comebacks are never guaranteed.
Yet Joyce has put his hand up. The industry now has to decide whether to take it.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.