Air New Zealand’s 787-9 dispatch reliability stands at 98.8 per cent, which is comparable with the current worldwide -9 fleet. seth jaworski

Sweeter Dreams

Boeing 787 Dreamliner

After the much-delayed delivery of Boeing’s 787 Dreamliner and entry into service with launch customer All Nippon Airways in October 2011 the aircraft made worldwide headlines… for all the wrong reasons. It’s well-documented lithium-ion battery problems, a three-month grounding of the global fleet in early 2013 and ongoing technical issues severely dented its image. TOM BALLANTYNE reports on where the Dreamliner is today and how well it is performing.

It is the kind of news an airline’s management just loves to hear.

When Air New Zealand did a comparison between its 777- 200ER and the 787-9 Dreamliner flying between Auckland and Shanghai the results were exactly what Boeing had promised.

This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
Login
Become a Member
To continue reading the rest of this article, please login.

or

To unlock all Australian Aviation magazine content and again unlimited access to our daily news and features, become a member today!
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
PRINT
$49.95 for 1 year Become a Member
See benefits
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
PRINT + DIGITAL
$99.95 for 1 year Become a Member
$179.95 for 2 years Become a Member
See benefits
  • Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
  • Access to the Australian Aviation app
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
  • Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
  • Daily news updates via our email bulletin
DIGITAL
$5.99 Monthly Become a Member
$59.95 Annual Become a Member
See benefits
  • Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
  • Access to the Australian Aviation app
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
  • Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
  • Daily news updates via our email bulletin

Economically, it turned out to be no contest. “We went up to Shanghai in a 777,” explained the carrier’s chief flight operations and safety officer Captain David Morgan.

“The following day the 787 went up there and over the same air distance, with winds the same on both days, the flight time about the same, the payload within a few hundred kilos – 29 tonnes on each day – the 777 burned 82 tonnes of fuel and the 787 burned 62 tonnes.

That’s 20 tonnes or 20 per cent and whichever way you look at it, that’s spectacular. ” Morgan doesn’t cite how much that amounts to in hard cash savedbut a quick back-of-the-envelope piece of arithmetic gives a pretty good indication. Over the 777, a daily 787 return flight to China from New Zealand would save more than 14,000 tonnes of fuel annually and, depending of course on the price of fuel, knock as much as $12 million from the carrier’s costs on a single route. And Air NZ, which last year was launch customer for the -9, already has three in service with 11 more to come over the next three years.

While Morgan says the -9 has exceeded all of the airline’s expectations nobody, including Boeing, is claiming that it has had a trouble-free entry into service since Air NZ launched it into the skies commercially last August.

What they do say, however, is that it has benefited significantly from the lessons learned from the numerous issues that arose with the -8. So far, the latest variant has hardly made the wrong side of the news at all.

As Boeing’s vice president of 787 and fleet services Mike Fleming put it in an exclusive interview with Australian Aviation: “I think each airplane that we develop benefits from the airplanes prior to it. We learn quite a bit as we go through development of the airplane as we put it into service and we incorporate these lessons into the products which come after it. We have certainly benefited from our experience on the -8 in producing the -9. ” Fleming says that “for the most part” Boeing is happy with the progress of the -9. “There’s a glass half full view and a glass half empty view and I’m the glass half empty guy because I focus on what’s wrong with the airplanes that go out there and fix that. As we have improved the reliability of the airplane the more recently delivered aircraft are performing more reliability than the ones we delivered way back in the start of 2011 and 2012 andthe -9 has been part of that. All of the improvements that we put into the -8, we incorporated into the -9.

There are still some issues we need to resolve there but it’s doing well, like all of the -8s we have been delivering around it. ” Fleming says most of the feedback from airline customers is positive.

“The reliability is not where we want it to be. It’s not where certainly some of the operators want it to be yet. Those that are not at the fleet average or at the upper end (of the reliability scale) we are working closely with to improve the operation of the airplane.

There’s still some systems that we need to fix. We know that and we are working very hard to get those fixed. ” This is good news for Qantas, which has 50 options and purchase rights on Dreamliners spread out over the remainder of the decade, although it has yet to make a decision on precisely when to trigger an order and arrange deliveries.

The decision is getting closer with Qantas chief executive Alan Joyce at the carrier’s half year financial results announcement in February making it clear there were a couple of important factors involved in pushing ahead with an order.

“The first is that we need to pay down debt. We’re targeting a net debt reduction of $1 billion this year.

We need to get the international division back into profit and we are obviously making really good progress on that and expect that to occur this year. And we have to have the right conditions. We are talking to our employees about getting that aircraft’s business case to work for us going forward. We are in good dialogue with the employee groups on that. So we are making progress on it,” he said.

“Everybody in Qantas wants to see these aircraft coming in but the aircraft have to make the right

Jetstar says the 787-8 is proving a “great aircraft”. rob finlayson
An Air India 787-8 departs Sydney Airport. seth jaworski
787-8 despatch reliability is moving towards 99 per cent across all operators. seth jaworski

Everybody in Qantas wants to see these aircraft coming in. ALAN JOYCE

return, have to be brought in under the right conditions and have to be brought in with a balance sheet that is strong enough to take it. ” With the airline almost certainly heading for a big profit in its current year ending June 30 it is more than likely that decision will come well before the end of this year. Qantas’s budget arm Jetstar already has eight 787-8s with three more to come this year. By September all of its long-haul flights will be operated by 787-8s in a two class 335-seat configuration. Jetstar head of engineering, Australia and New Zealand David Lau says the 787-8s have been “a great aircraft” for the carrier, “improving the customer experience while also delivering significant cost savings. ” But it has been a bumpy ride to get to this point. A 234-seat twin-aisle in typical three class configuration, the original 787-8 was first scheduled to come to market in May 2008 but production delays saw that stretch out to 2011. Its issues, quite apart from the lithium-ion battery problems that sparkedemergency landings resulting in the grounding of the entire fleet in early 2013 for three months, included everything from oil filter, fuel pump and brake problems, engines failing to start, power supply issues, icing issues with GEnx-powered aircraft and faults in air conditioning units.

It all added up to a bad image for Boeing’s most advanced aircraft whose total development and manufacturing cost were about $32 billion, five times more expensive that the company’s initial estimate. The list price of a -8 is US$218. 3 million and the -9 US$257. 1 million, while the -10, a double-stretch model scheduled to come into service in 2018, is listed at US$297. 5 million. Off course airlines pay nowhere near this figure – analysts suggest the -8 is being sold for as low as US$120 million – but it still represents a huge investment for carriers who want reliability and operational efficiency.

Today, there is little doubt that the major issues appear to be behind Boeing. Fleming points out there are now more than 240 Dreamliners

We have seen improvement across the vast majority of the systems on the airplane. MIKE FLEMING

flying and they’ve chalked up in excess of a million revenue flight hours, carrying upwards of 40 million passengers. “The really cool part of this is we’ve saved approximately 1. 8 billion pounds of fuel. It’s quite a bit,” he points out.

Nevertheless, a number of airlines have been publicly critical of the aircraft’s reliability, among them European budget operator Norwegian and Air India. Dispatch reliability is a key performance marker for any new aircraft because any delays due to technical faults cost money. But it is a complex equation because each operator measures it differently. Some count a delay as any flight departing after the scheduled time. Some use five minutes, others 10 minutes or even 15 minutes, which is generally accepted as the industry standard.

In addition there is the issue of delays caused by deferrable items, or faults that can be put on the minimum equipment list (MEL), when the aircraft can still operate with that fault.

Fleming says that in terms of the performance of the -8, it has improved remarkably. Boeing, which uses the 777 as a benchmark with its dispatch reliability of 99. 5 per cent, says that is the level it is trying to achieve with the 787.

“Since putting the airplane (the -8) into service, from a reliability standpoint it is performing very well. Not where we want it to be yet and not where all our customers want it to be yet but we are getting closer to 99 per cent on a three month moving average, with quite a bit of the fleet flying above 99 per cent today. So we have seen improvement across the vast majority of the systems on the airplane. There are still a few that we’re working hard to improve and when we get resolution for that I think we will see another marked improvement. “In terms of schedule reliability we tend to use industry standard rules and we’ve been measuring ourselves on the 787 to a much more stringent criteria, which is that even if an item is MEL-able to still charge the delay to the airplane. By that category we are just now approaching the 99 per cent mark. If you assumed that the MEL-able items are excluded from that, which is what a lot of the airplanes are reported at, we would actually be above 99 per cent today. When you talk about the 777 and the 99. 5 per cent range that is against the standard where they don’t count MEL-able items and so we are trying to approach and actually exceed the 777 reliability.

We are less than half a percentage point away from where the 777 was at this stage in its entry into service and we are possibly a little bit under half a percentage point under what the 777 is in general today. ” As for issues which Boeing is still dealing with, Fleming says the areas where it has the most focus and which offer the best opportunities for improving the aircraft’s reliability have to do with one of the flight control units and the brake control units. “We’ve made some software changes and we’re making hardware changes to resolve faults which generate in those boxes. If we get those resolved it will give us the greatest benefit. We also still have some improvements to make in the electrical power system. Nothing really major but this is the allelectric airplane so it touches almost everything on the airplane.

So we spend quite a bit of time there. We are also doing a little bit on our navigation and avionics components as well. ” Fleming says the issue with the brake system is not a major flaw.

“It has to do with the sensitivity of the control system to what we

Total 787 orders now stand at 1,073. keith anderson

The 777 had its share of challenges when we introduced that airplane as well. MIKE FLEMING

would call ‘noise’ in the system Total 787 orders now stand at 1,073. keith anderson from the electrical signal. If you have any kind of signal abnormality it can cause the box to trip and you generate a fault. Then the airline needs to go deal with that fault. We have to address that. We’ve also had some issues with moisture intrusion into some of the components which has caused faults that we’ve had to go address. It’s those kind of things.

Nothing of a real serious nature but they cause delays and they cause schedule interruptions so they are very important for us to go fix. ” He says there are really no unique -9 issues. “To be frank most of the delays that have been caused on that airplane have been for systems that were common to the -8. The first thing we do when it occurs is make sure we have the airline in a position to solve the problem and to make sure the airplane goes into service. ” Boeing has a 787 operational control centre in Seattle monitoring every aircraft that is flying 24/7.

“We are in close contact withour folks that are deployed out in the field and with our customers, sharing information with them.

As we see faults on the airplane we’ll assess whether or not we believe these faults could impact the operation and then we’ll move to make sure that we have the right support there to keep the operator going. If there is a faulty component that needs to come off the airplane we of course get that component, bring it back for engineering analysis to decide if there’s a systemic problem or an inherent flaw in the component that we need to go fix. If that’s the case we put a plan together and go fix it. ” As for its -9s, a 302-seat aircraft in a three class configuration, Air New Zealand reports no major issues. Its dispatch reliability stands at 98. 8 per cent, which is comparable with the current worldwide -9 fleet, says Morgan.

“That is where we would expect it to be for a new aircraft type.

The Dreamliner is an exceedingly customerfriendly
aircraft. boeing

There’s always some what wecall ‘infancy’ issues that you will see with a new aircraft coming to market. Our expectations are being met in that regard. The target will shift over time as the aircraft gets more mature so we are sitting where we think we should be with its technical dispatch reliability at the moment and we are satisfied with that. ” Morgan says it is clear a lot of the issues that arose with the -8 have been resolved in the -9.

“When the -9 came to market a lot of that stuff had been designed out in the -9 and so this aircraft has landed not only with us but with the worldwide fleet in a better position to be able to deal with those things. I know one of the issues they had was quite a technical one but for example the aircraft, when you make power changes, when you bring generators on line,there’s a power interruption. The aircraft’s ability to measure those power interruptions was clearly very precise and they actually needed to give it a little more time to confirm that the power change occurred. They just simply changed the software. A lot of the nuisance messages that were popping up as a result of a normal power change have all gone away.

That’s the difference between the -8 and the -9. ” Jetstar’s Lau doesn’t give a reliability level but says the airline has been improving the dispatch reliability performance and tracking towards world fleet average in the high 90s. “Our 787s are delivering strong fuel burn savings against traditional aircraft types,” he adds. “As with the introduction of any new aircraft type, there are a number of systems and processes that need constant refining to ensure performance is optimised. Jetstar isproactively reviewing and managing its systems and processes as part of industry best practices. ” Currently, Jetstar is flying its 787s around 13 hours a day, which Lau says will increase over time as the airline moves to an all-787 long-haul fleet.

It is also interesting to look at a comparison between the 787’s introduction and the 777, which entered service in 1995. Boeing’s Fleming played a similar role in the introduction of that widebody. “The 777 had its share of challenges when we introduced that airplane as well.

We tend to focus on how great the airplane is doing today. It’s reliability.

But we went through a similar maturity phase on that airplane as we are on the 787. As I look back I think a lot of the difference has to do with the social media, just in the sheer amount of reporting that happens on the 787 versus the 777. It’s much more on the 787 that we experienced on the 777. “But by the same token we have tools available to us today on the 787, such as our continuous monitoring of the fleet, we are able to do that we didn’t have on the 777. We are in the middle of this maturity phase on the 787 and having gone through that on the 777 I look back and I can’t even imagine how we did it on the 777 without many of the tools we have today. In many respects it seems somewhat easier to me today because of the tools that we have that we didn’t have back then. ” One thing on which there is universal agreement: the Dreamliner is an exceedingly customer-friendly aircraft.

Passengers like it. “It has exceeded our expectations. We are absolutely delighted with the aeroplane on a number of levels,” says Air NZ’s Morgan. “First and foremostthe customers love it. It’s got a great proposition in the cabin for our customers, they like what we’ve put in the aeroplane both in the premium cabins but also in economy. They clearly like the features of the aeroplane which we all know about, the windows, the comfort, the lighting, the subtle things like the pressurisation difference. On the customer metric scores the 787 is the most popular aircraft in the fleet and it is genuinely delivering a really good customer proposition. ” It is that propostion and popularity that has seen Boeing continue to ramp up 787 production rates. It is understood that internally Boeing was looking at delivering 138 new Dreamliners this year although publicly it puts the figure at between 124 and 127. Currently the production lines are scheduled to produce 10 aircraft each month, with plans for this to increase to 12 by 2016 and 14 in 2020. Boeing handed over only seven aircraft in January and 12 in February, including the first to Singapore Airlines budget operator Scoot, part of a 20 aircraft order originally placed by SIA for 10 -8s and 10 -9s. Some analysts have questioned whether Boeing will be able to reach its delivery target this year unless improvements are made to the production line.

A spokesperson for Boeing said the number of deliveries each month “can vary due to many factors, including factory and flight line flows and various customer considerations… this is normal for any manufacturing system… Boeing provides delivery guidance for Commercial Airplanes on a calendar-year basis”.

The Dreamliner order book now stands at 1,073, the latest commitment being for two -9s from Air Tahiti Nui. At the end of February 247 of these had been delivered.

While the 787 is now progressing well through its infancy it does continue to attract media attention, even for incidents that might normally not be reported. As recently as February an Air India 787-8 with over 120 passengers on board saw three of its four air conditioning units’ cabin air compressors (CAC) fail. They supply air and maintain pressure in the passenger cabin and have been the source of problems at several operators over the past two years. The Air India flight landed safely in Milan, where the aircraft was grounded. It had left Delhi with one of the units inoperative but this was allowable under the MEL. But two more CACs developed snags en route leaving just one functional. Such events are part and parcel of daily airline operations and given there was no threat to safety would rarely make headlines except for the fact it was a Dreamliner.

Boeing’s Fleming says this sort of publicity is not particularly frustrating. “I think it comes with the territory. I think the industry certainly and even the general public is always very interested in a new airplane when it goes into service. The 777 had focus on it. The A380 had focus on it and so has the 787. I think having gone through the 777 myself I understand that but it is a bit of a different world today, given the amount of social media that is out there now. Anything that happens seems to get published on the internet and it moves very quickly. That’s the world we live in now and so we adjust to it. I think the most important thing we can do to help our customers out and to help the folks who read that in the media is to just share information with our customers and everyone so they understand what’s happening around the fleet and what’s happening with our airplanes. ”

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.

You need to be a member to post comments. Become a member today!
Momentum Media Logo
Most Innovative Company
Copyright © 2007-2026 MOMENTUMMEDIA