Airbus and Boeing have spent decades making planes increasingly fuel-effi cient through new materials and aerodynamic design (Airbus)
Is sustainability sustainable?
As the aviation industry finally emerges from two years of total devastation, attention has been diverted back to another major issue at hand: sustainability.
Each year, aviation emits an estimated 1.04 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere – a figure that has doubled since the mid-1980s. It means the aviation sector today contributes between 2-3 per cent to the world’s carbon emissions per year, or roughly the same amount of CO2 emissions as all of Japan. Though, aviation’s emissions are set to rise without serious intervention as demand for air travel continues to grow.
Before the dawn of the COVID-19 pandemic in early 2020, sustainability was the biggest challenge to the aviation sector, and its discussion dominated industry events, forums, and financial reports. Glancing an eye over the run sheet for the CAPA Australia Pacific Aviation Summit in 2019, many of its panels and keynote speeches focused on gaining and maintaining the unprecedented growth across the aviation sector, announcing fleet and network expansions, mixed in with a side of innovative future solutions to lowering the sector’s emissions.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
By 2020, the now-entirely virtual program makes next-to-no mention of industry innovation or green aviation. Instead, each segment attempted to grapple with the weight of the COVID-19 pandemic and attempted to map out the industry’s escape route from such unchartered waters.
Another year on and the matter of sustainability has returned to the agenda with a vengeance. In fact, it has done so at conferences and annual general meetings around the globe, as the industry jumped behind increasing efforts towards decarbonising aviation.
In late 2019, Qantas became one of the first airlines to publicly commit to achieving net zero emissions by 2050. Exactly two years later, in October 2021, this goal became one that the entire aviation industry collectively agreed to strive towards, driven by the International Air Transport Association (IATA) and the Air Transport Action Group. At this point, airlines, airports, air traffic management organisations and engine makers jointly pronounced the importance of targeting net zero emissions.
The IATA’s public commitment to 2050 sparked what has been 12 months of major sustainability moves, as the industry follows up on its pledge. Boeing and Airbus teamed up with other original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) to push regulators to change the rules that dictate airlines can only operate with no more than 50 per cent sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) blended with 50 per cent traditional kerosene fuel, after arguing it is entirely safe for flights to operate on 100 per cent SAF. Shortly after, United Airlines made history after completing a nearly two-hour domestic flight between Chicago and Washington, DC, using 100 per cent SAF in one engine. The flight was used to gain traction to increase SAF allowances for airlines.
Closer to home, airlines have similarly changed their tune, or perhaps just started singing louder, when it came to sustainable initiatives.
Closer to home, airlines have similarly changed their tune, or perhaps just started singing louder, when it came to sustainable initiatives. Qantas and Air New Zealand both appointed an inaugural chief sustainability officer, signifying the importance of the task at hand to their businesses. Meanwhile, SAF made headlines here too, after Virgin Australia joined Qantas and Cobham in the Sustainable Aviation Fuel Alliance of Australia and New Zealand – a working group aimed at advancing the creation of sustainable fuel – while Qantas and Airbus teamed up to invest $200 million towards the development of a local sustainable fuel industry.
Why aviation?
It appears that together, the aviation sector is well and truly intending to follow through on this promise to lower its emissions and is heavily invested in finding any and all suitable solutions to achieve its carbon emissions goals. More on that, soon.
And yet, aviation is by no stretch of the imagination the largest carbon-emitting industry. While yes, across the globe, transport accounts for around 25 per cent of all carbon emissions – aviation accounts for just over one-tenth of this figure. In fact, by most accounts, the industry makes up just 2.5-3 per cent of the world’s yearly emissions. If this is the case, why is the aviation sector, in particular, taking such a strong, public and collective stance on the matter of sustainability?
An inevitability?
At its core, the aviation industry has always been dynamic and innovative, and that has, historically, led to lower emissions. As Pratt & Whitney’s chief sustainability officer Graham Webb puts it, improving efficiency, and as a byproduct, energy efficiency, is simply an inherent aspect of aviation technology over time. “Throughout the aviation industry as a whole, we’ve collectively worked to improve the fuel efficiency of aircraft significantly, up to 70 per cent since the 60s,” he says. “As a basic example, if you look at the Boeing 707 jet that was released in the late 50s and flew about 5,600 nautical miles at the time. It took four engines to achieve that type of range back then. Nowadays, you’re regularly flying that distance routinely with two engines. So as the technology advances, so too, do these solutions.”
Meanwhile, it’s quite obvious that in achieving this ability to procure aircraft with lower fuel burn and therefore lower emissions, airlines have been able to drastically reduce their costs, and increase their profits, right? Webb says that could be an over-simplification of the matter. According to airline CEOs Webb has dealt with, “commercially” it works out cheaper to keep and run older aircraft than it is to entirely renew a fleet to brand-new aircraft models, after accounting for lease and purchase costs, crew training, scheduling, and other operational matters. “I believe it was the EasyJet CEO who said this at a conference I attended in 2021, after the industry and IATA made its commitment to net zero by 2050,” Webb explains. “And he said, ‘So why am I buying all these brand-new aircraft that are more fuel efficient? It’s for the environment’.”
Like all publicly listed companies, many major aviation industries are kept accountable for their actions, and the delicate balance between achieving both environmental and financial goals is heightened. Here, the cynic in me wants to add that perhaps part of aviation’s pile-on to sustainability measures in recent years can also be chalked up to performative activism, or “greenwashing”. This is essentially pandering to a shareholder’s desire for the company to look sustainable, without actually caring whether or not it is.
For example, in March, Qantas announced its Green Tier frequent flyer program, which rewards loyalty members for engaging in sustainable activities such as offsetting their flights. Then, just one week later, the airline also announced that it would soon be producing and selling NFTs. NFTs are notorious and controversial for a number of reasons, however, are widely regarded as being extremely damaging to the environment due to the astronomical computing power required to store and sell them.
However, Professor Tim Ryley from Griffith University says that while the tactic of greenwashing can happen, it’s likely not often the case in aviation. “Like every organisation, there’s a new push for every decision to have a green element. This can come across like greenwashing, particularly since in aviation, lower emissions equals lower costs,” he says. “But it’s more likely that airlines are seeing a ‘mutually beneficial’ outcome by lowering their emissions. Because as time goes on, their need to go carbon neutral will only increase, and the ease at which they can do that to scale quickly will decrease, so efforts really need to start now.” Let’s get into that.
A growing problem
Despite the fact that aviation is, in practice, far from the biggest player in today’s CO2 emissions environment, this could change drastically if, and when, the other high-emitting industries revolutionise, which could see aviation left trailing the pack. Graham Webb of Pratt & Whitney says that as the rest of the world moves away from traditional fossil fuels, “aviation’s share of CO2 emissions will, naturally, increase”. According to the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO), the United Nations aviation body, aviation’s share of global emissions could triple by 2050, if left unchecked. In fact, even with the lower-emission engines on the market and sustainable aviation fuels capable of powering 50 per cent of the world’s flights, the rate of growth of the aviation industry means that emissions could still double by 2050. At the same time, scientists the world over agree that without a meaningful and deliberate attempt to reduce the impact of climate change, the world could soon face some of its devastating impacts, such as dramatic weather pattern changes and rising sea levels.
Additionally, with shareholders also comes responsibility. “There’s a motivation in society to improve our environmental footprint, and so, that dictates the decisions that aviation companies make,” Webb says. Professor Ryley agrees and says that major government-backed companies and publicly listed airlines alike are now kept to a degree of accountability when it comes to emissions. “With public aviation companies, there’s always an element of answering to their board members and answering to their customers. So the company has to respond to those needs accordingly, and, in this case, is held responsible for their ability to take carbon emissions seriously,” Ryley says.
Profit isn’t the only driver for optimal success anymore, and the needs of boards and customers can shift depending on localities, Ryley adds. This can therefore be influenced greatly by societal expectations and governance. For example, governments in Europe are generally very encouraging, if not forceful, on airlines to reduce carbon emissions. “So, arguably to date, airlines across Europe are therefore more committed to lowering their emissions than their US counterparts, because both governments and consumers, and ultimately board members, are supportive of that.” Importantly, this is a trend that can, and does, change. “To me, it was quite noticeable when the Biden administration entered government in the US, that airlines in that region also began to make more drastic moves towards sustainability. So boards and customers, but also even governments really drive some of these business decisions,” he says.
Scaling the mountain
Essentially, aside from natural innovation and lowering operating costs, the aviation industry needs to answer to the growing social, government, and shareholder expectations of green travel. Plus, as other industries get better at reducing their own emissions, aviation needs to catch up quickly if it wants to survive and thrive. However, achieving a carbon-neutral aviation industry is going to be no easy feat. According to Ryley, of all the major carbon-emitting industries, aviation is “one of the toughest” to scale back and will require the sector to band together in its efforts. Meanwhile, Webb agrees and says, “Aviation is one of the hardest sectors to decarbonise because at its core, what we do is take large amounts of weight – be that people or freight – and we transport them huge distances. And to do that, you require high energy density, so that’s the real challenge for us.”
“AVIATION NEEDS TO CATCH UP QUICKLY IF IT WANTS TO SURVIVE AND THRIVE”
Further, existing aviation technologies have likely already realised their dramatic windfalls in fuel efficiency, meaning any advancements in this space will likely only result in minor efficiency improvements. Ultimately, there are many ways to tackle the aviation emission mountain and the industry has already begun a multi-prong approach towards 2050. This involves fully adapting and adopting today’s technologies to be as green as possible, investing in the research and development of future revolutionary technologies, such as hydrogen or electric propulsion, and importantly, sustainable aviation fuels.
According to the IATA, about one-fifth of its strategy for seeing a carbon-neutral aviation industry by 2050 relies on carbon capture and carbon offsetting to compensate for the industry’s ongoing emissions after this point. A further 3 per cent of the zero emissions pie will come down to operational efficiencies being introduced at all levels of airlines, airports and through air traffic management. Thirteen per cent will rely on “new technologies”, which includes electric and hydrogen propulsion, and an overwhelming 65 per cent of its 2050 goal will come down to SAF.
Sustainable aviation fuels
Sustainable aviation fuels are considered to be a total game changer for aviation. It will largely be the catalyst for transforming today’s aviation technology into a lower-emissions version of itself. SAF will work in tandem with the increasing improvement of today’s aviation technology as a “bridge” between the aviation industry of today, and the next revolutionary development in the field.
SAF is essentially low-carbon jet fuel that is produced using sustainable feedstocks, such as used cooking oil, animal fat or solid waste from homes and businesses. Importantly, thanks to scientific developments, it’s now very similar in makeup to traditional fossil jet fuel and has the capacity to lower an aircraft’s emissions by up to 80 per cent. However, today, less than 1 per cent of all fuel utilised in aircraft is SAF, due to such limited supply worldwide.
In Australia, Qantas has recently stepped up its calls for the Australian government to support and invest in a local SAF production industry and pipeline. According to Qantas, its 1,500 daily flights see it use around 14 million litres of fuel every day, which accounts for about 95 per cent of the airline’s total emissions. A sovereign SAF production plant and pipeline would not only support Australia’s airlines but would also mark the beginning of a budding new resource industry on home soil.
Shortly thereafter, it was announced that the first sustainable aviation fuel and renewable diesel plant would be built in Gladstone, Queensland by Oceania Biofuels. The venture has been achieved in partnership with the Queensland government and is expected to be operational by 2025. Oceania Biofuels’ CEO Mike Everton says this renewable diesel and SAF plant is the result of more than two decades of development in biofuels.
“If you go back 20 years, biodiesel was what they call an additive – B5 or B10 – that was predominantly made from tallow, used cooking oil, and so on. But you could never use that as a pure fuel source,” he explains. Biodiesel would require its own separate infrastructure and be far less convenient for us on the scale that aviation and other major industries require.
“Today, we have what we now call renewable diesel, which is still made from feedstock, but it’s been hydrocracked – essentially been pulled apart and reconstituted back together – so that it looks and operates exactly the same as traditional diesel,” Everton says. “What that means is that this is now a drop-in fuel that doesn’t need new infrastructure, it can run through existing pipelines. It’s a straight fuel, which is huge for this industry.” Meanwhile, sustainable aviation fuel is “one step further” than renewable diesel and is hydrocracked again.
Aviation authorities have approved SAF created in this way for use in aircraft, up to a 50 per cent blend with traditional jet fuel. Further, according to Everton, all of today’s aircraft engines are capable of running on a blend of up to 50 per cent SAF. Despite this fact, it’s likely that we’re still many years away from seeing airlines running on even this level of SAF. “Currently, it’s more expensive to secure SAF than it is traditional aviation fuel, and the volume that we would need to operate at 100 per cent SAF is astronomical,” Everton notes. “Today, the aviation industry runs on about 1 per cent SAF, which could reach 7-8 per cent in 2030. By 2050, the industry, SAF industry, is hoping to expand its reach and its use of other plant-based oils and such, to hopefully achieve a split of 50 per cent SAF by then.”
With many airlines, Qantas included, aiming for a SAF blend of at least 10 per cent by 2030, Everton said Australia is “perfectly positioned” to become “totally self-sufficient” by 2035. “It’s not just us, there are others doing this and there should be more. We have the landmass, we have the water, we have the farmers that want to support it. Getting this from paddock to tank to wingtip, it’s an exciting opportunity and we’re not the only ones working towards this.”
Upon the opening of the Gladstone plant, Everton said he hopes to be producing 400 million litres of renewable diesel per year, with a goal to quickly scale up to 800 million litres per year. “Of that, about 70 per cent will be SAF specifically, and we’d like to see at least 80 per cent of that staying in the country.” Everton said Oceania is already in advance discussions with Qantas about providing the Flying Kangaroo with its future SAF, and has had meetings with Virgin Australia, too.
Adapting today’s technology
Aside from the widespread production and usage of SAF as an alternative to traditional jet fuel, another way to slash emissions is to invest in making current aviation technologies as green as possible. Lighter, more fuel-efficient aircraft are the cornerstone of this. Notably, as mentioned earlier, a lot of the heavy lifting in regard to the research, development and rollout of these solutions has already been done. OEMs – largely Airbus and Boeing, along with engine makers – have already spent decades trying to drive down operational costs of their airframe, and, as a result, have successfully managed to minimise the carbon footprint of traditional aviation technologies. Composite materials and smarter aerodynamic design, such as wingtips, help to lower emissions largely due to reducing weight, making the airframe lighter overall and therefore burning slightly less fuel.
It’s unclear where, or even if, the IATA’s roadmap to 2050 accounts for the adaption of traditional aviation technologies into greener, more energy efficient variants. It’s possible that the IATA has recognised that much of the development in this arena has already been achieved, and any future gains are likely to be far less significant. In which case, the only step to realise the gains achieved so far in making traditional aircraft more efficient is for airlines to retire their older aircraft in lieu of the newer, greener versions. “Fleet renewal is a major part of reducing emissions in today’s operating environment,” says Webb. “Essentially, airlines will say, ‘let’s get rid of our older gas-guzzlers that emit more CO2 and replace them with newer, more fuel-efficient aircraft’.” Given the 28-year timeframe to the 2050 net zero goal, this is likely to happen naturally as airlines renew their fleets with the market’s latest offerings.
“HYDROGEN FUEL IS BECOMING A REAL CONTENDER”
Here at home, Virgin Australia announced that its next generation domestic fleet would consist of the Boeing 737 MAX family, powered by CFM International LEAP-1B engines, while Qantas’ recent domestic fleet renewal announcement favoured the Pratt & Whitney GTF engines for both its incoming A220 and A320neo aircraft. Webb says engine technologies have also come a long way in reducing fuel burn and maximising efficiency. “The GTF, or geared turbofan, engine is a technology that we’ve worked on for over three decades now. It offers a 16 per cent improvement in fuel efficiency compared to the previous generation, while our GTF Advantage engine increases this to 17 per cent,” he says. “Let me put it this way, 750,000 gallons of water – about three million litres – drops down from Niagara Falls every second. If you were to watch The Godfather next to Niagara Falls, then the same amount of water that has fallen during that time is roughly equivalent to how much fuel airlines save with these next-generation engines over that period. That’s a massive outcome alone for operators, let alone on top of the other efficiencies built into the newer aircraft,” he says.
Racing towards radical alternatives
Scaling back to carbon neutrality as an industry that, before the pandemic, produced over one billion tonnes of CO2 per year is, well, to say ambitious is an understatement. However, with 28 years to go, the industry has a little time up its sleeve for something to come around and revolutionise the sector.
It’s quite clear that the industry has pinned high hopes that revolutionary technologies can intervene and save the day in order to make the 2050 net zero goal well within reach. According to the IATA, 13 per cent of its 2050 carbon neutrality target is set to be achieved via “new technology”, including electric and hydrogen. The industry body has stated that over 1,703 megatonnes of carbon emissions could be eradicated from the industry between 2031 and 2035, assuming that “evolutionary technology” allows the industry to achieve a “30 per cent reduction in fuel burn”, while “electric/hydrogen aircraft” come online for regional markets (up to 90 minutes and 100 seats). By 2040, forecast targets rely on developments such as working prototypes on “new aircraft such as blended wing bodies”, along with, again, electric or hydrogen-powered flight with a slightly longer range than the previous – up to 120 minutes.
Of course, companies, researchers, scientists are all hard at work to design, build and introduce these solutions, which genuinely would be revolutionary to aviation. In fact, some developments could be a much-needed catapult for aviation’s green endeavours.
According to Patti Harburg-Petrich, the US aviation lead at global consultancy firm Buro Happold, advancements in hydrogen propulsion could be a huge win for aviation. “Hydrogen propulsion is what we call carbon positive, because it’s not actually polluting any CO2 into the atmosphere,” she says. Harburg-Petrich says that the research and investment that has gone into hydrogen solutions, even during the pandemic years, has meant that what once was a fantasy could soon be a reality. “If you asked me a year or two ago, I would have told you that the future of hydrogen flight was very much still aspirational. But now, hydrogen fuel is becoming a very real contender,” she says. In 2020, a hydrogen-fuelled Piper M-Class, developed by California-based start-up ZeroAvia, performed its first successful test flight. “And the best part about it, is that its emissions are water and oxygen, both of which we could use more of here, as opposed to CO2.”
Despite her optimism, hydrogen is far from a perfect solution for multiple reasons. One reason is that hydrogen is literally lighter than air and would need to be turned to liquid and stored at well below freezing temperatures in order to be used effectively as a fuel source. This requires heavy infrastructure – fuel tanks – which drastically reduces its effectiveness in aviation.
Electric-powered aircraft are another green solution that has already proven itself to be a possibility. Outside of a scale up of renewable diesels, electricity is easier to make cleaner today. “We know that electric aviation is feasible, because we’ve seen it,” Professor Ryley says. “Flights are short-haul and regional right now, but that could be expanded in the future.” Investment in supersonic technology has also been touted as a no-emission, ultra-fast mobility solution, though again, this one has plenty of sceptics too.
No right answer
Professor Ryley says that ultimately, “none of these solutions are perfect today”, and each bares certain baggage. “With electric aircraft, we are limited in our range and travel time, whereas with biofuels we have to tackle things like food security issues, and there’s no supply chain right now. Meanwhile, hydrogen propulsion, as a whole, is still a question mark at the moment,” he says. “The solutions will likely take different forms in different places, where one of these problems might not pose such a significant threat to the rollout of that solution. But there’s no obvious ‘holy grail’ solution to sustainable aviation, it seems much more likely that we’ll chip away at all of them until we get there.” This was one sentiment that was shared by Pratt & Whitney’s Webb. “There’s no question that the next 10 to 15 years is going to be significant and disruptive in terms of aviation technology,” he said. “Be it electrification, hydrogen, we’re working on a hybrid-electric propulsion system right now. We’re likely to see many, or all of these things come to fruition by 2050 though, and it just shows again innovation driving our industry forward.”
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.