Aerocircus | The 1 In 60 Rule: Part 2
Aero Circus is run by a small group of pilots who are independent of airlines, employers, flying schools or other industry associations. They attempt to write unbiased articles with the aim of helping pilots of any experience level get more out of aviation. Check them out at aerocircus.com.au.
Last time we explored the basics of 1 in 60 navigation, including the history, maths behind the rule and a few basic examples. In Part 2 we will apply this knowledge to more practical examples and real-world applications
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
Real example: Moorabbin to Bairnsdale
Let’s say a pilot departs Moorabbin Airport intending to fly on a track of 075⁰ magnetic direct to Bairnsdale Airport, 120 NM away. Our pilot has decided to do clearoff checks every 20 NM in the aircraft being flown today. We will assume the pilot has climbed to the planned altitude for the flight before leaving Moorabbin and can therefore maintain a constant speed and heading. At the first 20 NM ‘checkpoint’ the pilot is able to positively identify a small town directly below and marks the current position on the map as point ‘A’.
The track made good (TMG) or actual flight path is represented by the blue line below. This is measured (using the pilot’s protractor and map) as being 3 NM to the left of the FPT. Please note the angles in the following diagrams have been exaggerated for clarity.
From the 1 in 60 rule, we can quickly determine that as the aircraft has drifted 3 NM off track in 20 NM, if nothing changes it would be 6 NM off track at the 40 NM mark and 9 NM off track by the time the 60 NM mark is reached. Therefore, the aircraft is currently travelling 9⁰ to the left of the flight planned track (FPT). This calculation is the first part of a two-step process. It determines the track error.
If the pilot now changes the heading by 9⁰ to the right to correct the track error, the aircraft will fly parallel to the desired track. This is represented by the red line below.
In practical terms, to fly the FPT of 075⁰ we must add 9⁰ to correct the track error which requires a Heading of 075⁰ + 9⁰ = 084⁰.
This is better than continuing on the original heading but usually has only fixed half of the problem. The exception may be when both the track error and the distance travelled are small. In this case simply adjusting by the amount of the track error will probably get you close enough to your destination, given the range of other variables involved that are constantly trying to send you somewhere you really don’t want to go.
But for larger errors, the pilot must now close the angle to be able to arrive at Bairnsdale. If there was only 20 NM left to run (instead of 100 NM as is the case here), the closing angle would also be 9⁰. We now have 2 options.
- A more straightforward calculation
The simplest calculation would be to double the track error amount of 9 degrees, giving a closing angle of 18 degrees. This would bring us back onto the FPT at the 40 NM mark in this example, or at double the distance already travelled for any example. For small errors this is probably preferable as it restores the original FPT without wasting a lot of time and fuel. And you won’t need to draw new lines all over your map. Unfortunately, it also contains the largest calculation error when compared to results derived from trigonometry.In practical terms, to return to the FPT at the 40 NM mark we must add 9⁰to correct the track error plus 9⁰ to for the closing angle which requires a Heading of 075⁰ + 9⁰ + 9⁰ = 093⁰.Hot tip: Don’t forget once you intercept the original FPT once again, you will need to readjust your heading by 9⁰ degrees to the right of your original heading (on the same heading as the red parallel track above) otherwise you will just repeat the same error again. The revised heading once ‘back on track’ would be 075⁰ + 9⁰ = 084⁰.This technique can also be applied if you need to divert around obstacles such as cloud, smoke, restricted areas, etc. - A slightly more complex calculation
A slightly more complex calculation is required if the new track is to aim directly at the final destination (Bairnsdale in this example). Instead of considering angles, we need to go back to the distances.After applying the 9⁰ track error correction, we are still 3 NM off – and flying parallel to – the original FPT. We also need to adjust for 3 NM to the right over the remaining 100 NM. The correct calculation is 60 / 100 x 3 = 1.8⁰ (2⁰ will do).So, the pilot should turn right by 9⁰ to correct the track error, plus another 2⁰ to pick up the closing angle. Therefore, with no other variables, adjusting the heading at point A by 11⁰ to the right will place the aircraft on the correct track to arrive at the intended destination of Bairnsdale. In our practical example this is 075⁰ + 9⁰ + 2⁰ = 086⁰.
A few more hot tips
The distances are not always accommodating, but this 1 in 60 technique is very flexible. Sixty is divisible by 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 10, 12, 15, 20, 30 and 60, which makes it easy to deal with a wide range of distance values in your head. However, distances are not always conveniently relatable to 60. A calculator or flight computer can help.
In the air, I always ask myself: “What do I have to do to the distance travelled to make it equal 60?”. Then I apply that answer to the track error measurement.
A few examples
- Distance 12 NM: 12 x 5 = 60.
- Distance 15 NM: 15 x 4 = 60
- Distance 80 NM: 80 / 4 = 20 x 3 = 60
- Distance 150 NM: 150 / 5 = 30 x 2 = 60
Of course, it is not always easy to do simple maths in an airplane. Just add a couple of factors – instructor or examiner on board, marginal weather and so on – and even the easiest calculations require you to be a math genius. In this case, the flight computer or a calculator may save you from embarrassment.
A more complex example: Camden to Canberra
For this example, we have departed Camden Airport and for reasons inexplicable we want to fly to Canberra, 107 NM away. Due to a battle with turbulence we had to focus on holding a constant heading of 212⁰ as far as possible and did not have time to check our position against the map. Once things settle down we find ourselves overhead Mittagong airfield. Checking our trusty map, we find this to be 24 NM (measured along the FPT) from our departure point at Camden and 8 NM left of the FPT. What is the heading change required to compensate for the drift experienced and new heading so that we may now fly direct to Canberra?
First, we need to calculate the distance left to run. This is 107 – 24 = 83 NM. Now there are a few different ways to complete the remaining calculations.
Some solutions
Here are four possible ways to solve this, presented in order of increasing accuracy.
- Mental calculations
If using mental arithmetic, you should ask yourself “What do I need to do to 24 to make it equal 60?” One possible answer in this case is to halve it (12) then multiply by 5. Now apply this result to the track error of 8 NM. Half of 8 equals 4, multiplied by 5 equals 20. This means our track error is 20 degrees left, and we need to turn 20 degrees to the right to fly parallel to the FPT.
Another option is to look at the relationship between the distance travelled (24 NM) and the distance off track (8 NM). In this case 8 is exactly one third of 24. We can simply apply this ratio to 60. One third of 60 is 20.
Next, we need to determine the closing angle. We use the same process but with the distance to run instead of the distance already flown. From our earlier calculation this is 83 NM. What do we need to do to 83 to make it equal 60? Roughly divide by 4 (about 21) then multiply by 3 (about 63). Not exact but close enough. So 8 NM divided by 4 equals 2, multiplied by 3 equals 6⁰.
Finally, our required heading change is 20 + 6 = 26 degrees to the right of the original heading.
This method is probably only going to work for those who regularly practice mental calculations, don’t drink a lot and have no friends. Although you could jot down the steps on whatever you use to take notes during the flight if that helps.
- Flight computer
It is easy with the flight computer as it measures in the base of 60. Note that middle and outer scales can be interchanged in the following examples.
For the Tracking Error, set the Distance Travelled (24) on the middle scale against Distance Off Track (8) on the outer scale. Now read the result on the outer scale opposite the Rate arrow (60), which is the Tracking Error of 20.0 (degrees).
For the closing angle, set the distance remaining (83) on the middle scale against distance off track (8) on the outer scale. Now read the result on the outer scale opposite the rate arrow (60), which is 5.8⁰.
So, the total heading change required is 20.0 + 5.8 = 25.8 degrees to the right of the original heading. If you forget how to do the calculation it is summarised on the sliding section of the E6B. Refer to the user’s manual for other types of flight computer. Note that the Jeppesen wheel we used gave a slightly different result for some calculations.
- Calculator
Flight computers are reasonably accurate, but for a slightly more precise result, let’s do the 1 in 60 maths correctly using a calculator.
First, the ratio of 60 to 24 must be applied to the 8 NM track error. 60/24 x 8 = 20.000. So, we need to turn right 20⁰ to run parallel to the intended track.
For the closing angle, the ratio of 83 to 60 must be applied to 8NM. 60/83 x 8 = 5.783⁰.
Therefore, the total heading change required is 20.000 + 5.783 = 25.783 degrees to the right of the original heading.
Because the heading change required is greater than my personal 1 in 60 rule limit I would recheck and tweak the revised FPT to Canberra at the next CLEAROFF check point or positive position fix.
- Trigonometry
The most accurate way to solve the problem is by using trigonometry. Because we know the length of the adjacent and opposite sides of a right-angle triangle, we can use the tangent function to calculate the angle that we need to know. This gives us a track error of 18.435 degrees, and the closing angle is 5.505 degrees, giving a total heading change of 23.940 degrees to the right of the original heading.
Warning: The repeated use of trigonometry may cause brain paralysis
and loss of friends. Always consult your mathematical practitioner before use.
The best method?
As you can see, all three 1 in 60 methods produce fairly similar results, which are not too much different to the trigonometry results. Had we rounded down as suggested earlier, the results would have been even closer.
Given that even an experienced pilot when hand-flying would be lucky to steer with 2 degrees (and often within 5 degrees) of the desired track, each method is more than acceptable. Just use whatever works for you given the tools available to you at the time and what you are comfortable with. Or better still, use 2 of the methods as a cross-check.
Another way to think about 1:60
From the above results, the new heading that we would like to maintain is the original heading (212⁰) plus 20⁰ track error plus 6⁰ closing angle equals 238⁰.
We can simplify the above diagram into two right angle triangles to better illustrate the underlying calculations.
- The magenta triangle (left) represents the track error calculation (60 / 24 * 8 = 20).
- The green triangle (right) represents the closing angle calculation (60 / 83 * 8 = about 6).
- The heading change is the sum of the two calculations (20 + 6 = 26).
In this way all 1 in 60 calculations can be represented by using 2 right angle triangles.
But wait, there’s more
But there is another factor that may have the greatest effect on whether or not your calculations result in your arrival at the required location. All of the above theory is fine when there is no wind. But as the wind strength increases, so does its influence on the ultimate direction of the aircraft.
Once again, the greater the track error and therefore the heading correction required, the greater the influence the wind will have on the results. Hence there are two likely scenarios that will result from your initial heading correction. You will likely either undershoot or overshoot the FPT depending on where the ‘apparent’ wind on your new heading is coming from. Of course, there is also the (highly unlikely) possibility that you made a calculation error.
This requires an extra step in the navigation process. It is rarely taught and usually catches most pilots out.
The overshoot
What happens when the initial track error was corrected by too much and we then sailed blissfully across the FPT as shown below.
Again, using the Camden to Canberra example, at Mittagong we applied the heading changes from 1 in 60, and tracked down the red line below, with a new heading of X⁰.
Tip: I use the term ‘X⁰’ here rather than a specific number because we are only interested in the most recent heading. If we use the original heading adjusted by the 1 in 60 adjustment calculated earlier, that may or may not be the heading that we ended up flying.
Not Important: We could refer to it as the ‘read heading’ but some might misinterpret that as unnecessary information.
We now find ourselves overhead the Goulburn CBD, 6 NM to the right of the FPT. This is 65 NM from Camden and 42 NM from Canberra along the FPT.
On the FPT, the last leg stretched from the 24 NM mark (abeam Mittagong Airport) to the 65 NM mark (abeam Goulburn CBD). This is a distance of 41 NM. The lateral change over that distance was 8 NM (above the FPT in the above diagram) plus 6 NM (below the FPT) giving 14 NM.
Red hot tip: In this particular instance it is important to remember to add both sides of the track error and not just the one below the FPT.
Once again, we will simplify the above diagram into right angle triangles.
- In this case the magenta triangle (left) is no longer relevant (as it is not part of this leg) and can be ignored.
- The red triangle (middle) represents the track error calculation (60 / 41 * (8 + 6) = 20 (rounded down)). We need to turn left 20⁰to fly parallel with the FPT.
- The green triangle (right) represents the closing angle calculation (60 / 42 * 6 = 8 (rounded down)). We need to turn a further 8⁰left to track direct to Canberra.
- Therefore, the total heading change required is the sum of the two calculations (20 + 8 = 28).
When applied to the heading of X⁰ from the previous ‘red’ leg (see above), this should provide the green track from Goulburn to Canberra as shown below.
The undershoot
This happens when the heading correction was not sufficient to regain the FPT by the intended point. Hopefully this will be identified before the intended destination is passed, and a further adjustment to the heading can be made.
Let’s revisit the Camden to Canberra example from earlier. Perhaps the turbulence caused us to not hold the heading we thought we did. Perhaps we forgot to add the closing angle to the track error angle when calculating the new heading. Or perhaps the effect of the wind on the new heading resulted in a different result to the one we were expecting.
Whatever the reason, we tracked down the red line below and now find ourselves overhead the town of Bungonia, about 7 NM to the left of the FPT. This is 62 NM from our starting point at Camden and 45 NM from our destination of Canberra (measured along the FPT).
If we don’t revise our heading at Bungonia, we will not track directly to Canberra Airport. We have two options here.
- Continue on current heading
As our track is still converging with the FPT, if the visibility is good enough and our altitude is high enough, we should be able to visually identify Canberra (and therefore the airfield) in about 40 NM on the current heading. We can then immediately track visually to the airfield (or the inbound reporting point as appropriate). We may also choose to alter our heading to the right by a guestimate of 5 or 10 degrees. This may or may not help depending on the circumstances. - Revise the heading
If the visibility is poor or we are flying at low altitude due to cloud, fear of heights, etc., we may need to determine the further change to the heading that will point us at Canberra and track down the green line below.
Once again, we will simplify the above diagram into right angle triangles.
- As in the previous case the magenta triangle (left) is no longer relevant (as it is not part of this leg) and can be ignored.
- The blue triangle (middle) represents the track error calculation (60 / 38 * 1 = 1 (rounded down)). Here this is actually negative 1 because we are not moving away from the FPT as in the other examples. In other words, if we turn right -1⁰(i.e. turn left 1⁰), we would then track parallel to the FPT. You can see this visually as a ‘disconnect’ between the blue and brown triangles in the diagram above.
- The brown triangle (right) represents the closing angle calculation (60 / 45 * 7 = 9 (rounded down)). We need to turn 9⁰right from parallel to track direct to Canberra.
- Therefore, the total heading change required is the sum of the two calculations (-1 + 9 = 8).
When 8⁰ is added to the heading from the previous (red) leg, this should send us down the green track from Bungonia to Canberra as shown below.
The process for this is simple (in theory): Fly in a straight line at a constant, known, calibrated airspeed (CAS).
- Mark Point A on the map
- Maintain a constant heading and airspeed until Point B
- The difference between heading and track gives wind direction
- The difference between CAS and ground speed (GS) gives wind speed in the direction of travel
In this example, we have just departed from Tibooburra Airport are planning to fly east across the western plains of NSW. Since it hasn’t rained for a while, it’s just one big dust bowl. There are a few roads and homesteads along the track that we can make out from our altitude, but not much else.
As we pass over Clifton Downs homestead (positively identifiable because the name is painted on the roof) we note the time on our watch as 1020 and assign this location ‘Point A’ on our WAC. As accurately as possible we steer our pre-calculated heading of 090⁰ magnetic (from the flight plan) and maintain a calibrated airspeed (CAS) of 120 knots. In case you have forgotten, CAS is indicated airspeed corrected for temperature and altitude plus instrument error.
Exactly 20 minutes later we pass over the top of Borrona Downs homestead. Our watch now reads 1040 and we assign this ‘Point B’ on the WAC. We use our plotter (or whatever tools we have to hand) to measure the distance between the 2 locations. We find this to be exactly 30 NM, and the track between them (which is 100⁰ magnetic). We now have all the data we need to calculate wind speed and drift.
Nil wind expectations
Had we flown the above sector with no wind, we would expect to have headed 090⁰ and taken 30 NM / 120 NM/H = 15 minutes to traverse that distance.
Actual results
- Direction
For direction, we flew a heading of 090⁰but ended up actually tracking 100⁰, so the wind blew us 10⁰ to the right of our FPT (drift). In other words, the wind is blowing from the left of our track (in this case from the north) and we are drifting right (south) of track. Therefore, to fly our FPT of 090⁰ we must correct for this and steer a Heading of 10⁰ into wind (in this case 080⁰). - Speed
As for speed, we flew 30 NM in 20 minutes. If we kept going with no changes, we would therefore fly 3 x 30 NM (= 90 NM) in 3 x 20 minutes (= 1 hour). Therefore, our ground speed is 90 knots. A simple comparison of a nil wind (or calibrated) airspeed of 120 expected versus 90 actual means that we flew 30 knots slower than if there was no wind. Therefore, the headwind component is 30 knots.In reality, the wind is blowing from somewhere between north/east at something more than 30 knots, but this information is of no use to us when we already have the headwind and drift. During WWII, an extension of this technique was used by the allies. The mission leader would fly in a straight line, plotting a first reference point, then fly in a noted heading for a certain amount of time and identify a second point. From this he was able to calculate the wind direction and speed, using the knowledge to plot a heading to the destination.
Summary
Here are some key points that you should have taken from the above explanations.
- The 1 in 60 rule is not totally accurate but certainly good enough for most aerial navigation situations.
- Measuring distances only along the FPT (for distances travelled or remaining) or at right angles to this for distance off track will give the most accurate results.
- There are limits to the use of 1 in 60, which you should understand and determine for your current skill level.
- Mental calculations, even with rough rounding, will produce a result that is more than adequate for most navigation situations. Flight computers or calculators can be used if the pilot’s brain is not ‘playing ball’ for any reason.
- Every 1 in 60 navigation problem can be broken down into two right angle triangles.
- When using 1 in 60, if you round down instead of up whenever rounding is required, the final result will usually be more accurate (when compared with the trigonometric answer).
- The 1 in 60 rule can be used multiple times along the same flight leg, but you need to understand the finer points of it to make it work correctly.
- The rule has far more applications than the basics covered here, both in aviation and everyday life. Regular practice will make in-flight calculations easier in time.
So, there you have it – more than you ever wanted to know about 1 in 60. Like everything else in aviation, it is a perishable skill that needs regular practice. Maybe on your next cross-country trip, leave the EFB in the LFB (leather flight bag) and get back to basics. You might need to call on those basic skills for real one day.
On the subject of 1 in 60, it has a multitude of uses in everyday life as well. I use it regularly when calculating the fall on a patio roof, for example. If the roof is 6 metres long and I need to provide a 3 degree fall, then it is a simple mental calculation to determine that one end of the roof must be 300mm lower than the other.
Aero Circus is run by a small group of pilots who are independent of airlines, employers, flying schools or other industry associations. They attempt to write unbiased articles with the aim of helping pilots of any experience level get more out of aviation. Check them out at aerocircus.com.au.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.