Opinion: Australia, it’s time for ‘the talk’ on national security
The federal government’s recent Defence Strategic Review ruled out B-21s in favour of long-range F-35 missiles. What does it mean for the RAAF and our wider approach to defence?
Like any adolescent, there comes a point when our parents sit us down and have ‘the talk’. For Australia, that time has come, and rather than being a talk about the birds and the bees, this conversation will be equally awkward, yet necessary. For many historians, strategic thinkers, and political decision makers, the horrors of WWII could accurately be seen as the final, most painful stages of labour before the birth of the new world order.
As the fires of conflict finally subsided, bringing the conflict to an end across Europe and the vast expanse of the Pacific, people everywhere breathed a sigh of relief as the carnage and horrors of the previous six years were replaced by a renewed sense of optimism and hope.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
Striding triumphantly across the ashes of Europe’s formerly great imperial powers, the United States and the Soviet Union sought to usher in a new period of prosperity and optimism. Sadly, the elation and optimism of the early post-war days came crashing down as an iron curtain descended across much of Soviet-occupied Europe, and competition between the two superpowers began to take shape.
The economic, political, and strategic competition that would begin to take shape as the US and the Soviet Union eyed off one another across the globe would become known as the Cold War, a period of intense, often sporadically hot competition between the two superpowers.
This intense competition saw vast arsenals of weapons developed and fielded, proxy conflicts fought across multiple continents, and intriguing games of espionage between the two camps, as former KGB officer Yuri Bezmenov explained, to engage in “ideological subversion”.
While the collapse of the Soviet Union came as somewhat of a surprise to many strategic thinkers and political leaders, the world embraced the “new world order” and the triumph of liberal democratic capitalism over the horrors of autocratic tyranny at this end of history, something we now know is fraught with hubris.
As the US-led world order completed a self-congratulatory lap of honour and took to expanding democracy across the world, particularly in the Middle East, the former Soviet bloc licked its wounds. It began the long, arduous journey back towards relevance and a position of prominence on the global stage.
Today, the new revolutionary world order would not be led in major part by Russia; rather, it would be spearheaded by Mao’s China, a juggernaut that extensively studied the lessons of history and has never quite recovered from its “Century of Humiliation” at the hands of colonial empires, with its eyes on usurping the global status quo.
In the face of these challenges, Australia is at the edge of a precipice of immense change. The post-WWII order, established in the war’s dying days and formalised with the Bretton Woods Conference and the formation of the United Nations, set the stage for stability, prosperity, and growth, which transformed the world despite periods of tumult.
Despite these challenges and the long-awaited release of the Albanese government’s Defence Strategic Review (DSR), the Australian public is more broadly being left out of a critical conversation about the nature of the challenges facing Australia. It is time for the Australian government to have ‘the talk’ with the Australian people.
Let’s be frank in our conversations with the Australian people. With the release of the DSR and the preceding 2020 Defence Strategic Update and supporting Force Structure Plan, both sides of Australian politics have started, albeit somewhat tentatively, to shift public dialogue about the challenges Australia faces in an increasingly multipolar world.
The timid nature of the language in documents like the DSR ultimately does more to hinder a coordinated “whole-of-nation” response as the DSR seeks to begin coordinating.
Highlighting this point, Peter Jennings AO, speaking at the DSR Summit – hosted by Australian Aviation’s sister brand Defence Connect – explained the DSR “misreads the source of the risk, the source of the risk is China”. Explaining further, he said, “It misreads that we are just watching this (on the sidelines), but we are actually heavily invested in this [US-China] competition. I think that language is giving the government an opportunity not to talk about China … These three paragraphs would have to have been the three most talked about in the review.
“I am pleased that the document has said what we all know to be true, but there is plenty of transparency about what China is doing. (It can be found) In Xi Jinping’s speeches and writing, government documents; strategy running counter to the current global order,” Jennings told the audience.
It’s important to highlight Australia will face an increasingly competitive Indo-Pacific in the coming era of multipolarity. Separate from the People’s Republic of China, our immediate region is home to some of the world’s largest populations and fastest-growing economies with their own unique designs and ambitions for the region.
Nations like Indonesia, India, Vietnam, Thailand, and the Philippines in our immediate region combined with other powers like Japan, South Korea, and Pakistan all have unique ambitions towards the region and their position in it separate from those of Xi Jinping’s China, presenting equally challenging circumstances for Australia’s position.
Both the Australian government and DSR only emphasise the challenges presented by Beijing and its Indo-Pacific designs, which need to be addressed directly and thoughtfully with the Australian public.
“Australians aren’t silly and are, to a certain extent, ahead of our politicians at the moment,” Jennings explained to the audience.
It can’t be all doom and gloom. Australia’s strategic policy and political leaders often overlook the need to avoid a “doom and gloom” narrative without presenting engaging solutions.
Instead, in the face of these challenges, we need to be presenting the opportunities that balance the challenges and do so honestly and directly. Equally, we need to see Australia begin to play the long game to fully capitalise on the opportunities to transform the Indo-Pacific.
Now, the most critical question is: when will we see a more detailed analysis and response to the challenges and opportunities facing Australia, and when will we see a narrative that better helps industry and the Australian public understand the challenges faced and opportunities we have presented before us?
There’s no doubt Australia’s position and responsibilities in the Indo-Pacific region will depend on our ability to sustain our nation economically, strategically, and politically in the face of rising regional and global competition. Despite our virtually unrivalled wealth of natural resources and agricultural and industrial potential, there’s a lack of a cohesive national security strategy integrating the development of individual yet complementary public policy strategies to support a more robust Australian role in the region.
Enhancing our capacity to act as an independent power serves as a powerful symbol of Australia’s sovereignty in supporting the security and prosperity of Indo-Pacific Asia; this is particularly well explained by Peter Zeihan, who explains: “A deglobalised world doesn’t simply have a different economic geography, it has thousands of different and separate geographies. Economically speaking, the whole was stronger for the inclusion of all its parts. It is where we have gotten our wealth and pace of improvement and speed. Now the parts will be weaker for their separation.”
Shifting the public discussion and debate away from the default Australian position of “it is all a little too difficult, so let’s not bother” will provide unprecedented economic, diplomatic, political and strategic opportunities for the nation. As events continue to unfold throughout the region and China continues to throw its weight around, can Australia afford to remain a secondary power, or does it need to embrace a larger, more independent role in an era of increasing great power competition?
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.