Opinion: Alan Joyce v the world

The CEO of Qantas admits he was one of Australia’s most divisive business leaders – but how will his enemies judge him?

There’s an old saw that states you can judge a man by the quality of his enemies. Based on this notion, outgoing Qantas CEO Alan Joyce was a titan among men indeed. Over the course of his 15 years at the helm of the Flying Kangaroo, Joyce made enemies of the unions, the ACCC, his own shareholders on occasion, and by the end a hefty chunk of the flying public, with Qantas becoming the nation’s most-complained-about airline.

Now – after his observation last August that he’s “had more resignation requests than any other CEO and probably any other public figure out there” – Alan Joyce is finally making his exit from the national carrier, with CFO Vanessa Hudson being anointed his successor to take over the reins at the company’s AGM in November. But what will we remember from Joyce’s tenure?

This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
Login
Become a Member
To continue reading the rest of this article, please login.

or

To unlock all Australian Aviation magazine content and again unlimited access to our daily news and features, become a member today!
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
PRINT
$49.95 for 1 year Become a Member
See benefits
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
PRINT + DIGITAL
$99.95 for 1 year Become a Member
$179.95 for 2 years Become a Member
See benefits
  • Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
  • Access to the Australian Aviation app
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
  • Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
  • Daily news updates via our email bulletin
DIGITAL
$5.99 Monthly Become a Member
$59.95 Annual Become a Member
See benefits
  • Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
  • Access to the Australian Aviation app
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
  • Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
  • Daily news updates via our email bulletin

Joyce v the unions

There can be little doubt that among many blood feuds sparked by Joyce’s oft-pugnacious management style, his decade-plus-long war with the unions has been one of the most enduring.
Back in 2011, in response to industrial action by unions including the Transport Workers Union and the Australian and International Pilots Association, Joyce took the unprecedented step of grounding the entire Qantas fleet. Flights that had already boarded were ordered to disembark, flights in the air were grounded at their next destination, and there were multiple reports of taxiing planes turning around on the runway.

This earned him the fierce enmity of both unions, with AIPA vice-president Richard Woodward describing the grounding as “a knife to the nation’s throat” and Tony Sheldon, secretary of the TWU, calling it “a pre-conceived, pre-planned attempt to hoodwink the shareholders, hoodwink the Australian community”.

The unions have never forgiven Joyce for the 2011 fleet grounding or for other transgressions in the years that followed, including the move during COVID-19 to outsource 1,700 ground handlers, which has been blasted as an “illegal sacking” and challenged back and forth all the way up to the High Court. Tony Sheldon – now an ALP Senator from NSW – held nothing back in response to the announcement of Joyce’s retirement, saying he should “give Qantas workers and customers an early Christmas present” by resigning early instead of waiting until November.

“Clearly, the CEO resigning is not enough. The Qantas board, which greenlit every greedy, illegal action taken throughout the Joyce era, desperately needs renewal,” he said. “Alan Joyce has left a massive task for the next CEO, who must restore the spirit of Australia to Qantas and end Alan Joyce’s ideological war on its loyal workforce and frustrated customers.”

Joyce v consumers

It’s not just the unions who’ve had plenty of bones to pick with Qantas over the Joyce years – the airline and consumer groups plus the ACCC have been at each other’s throats as well, with repeated disputes over matters such as the Flying Kangaroo’s attempt to buy FIFO operator Alliance, which the ACCC recently rejected after four delays.

One recent bugbear for the watchdog and other consumer advocates such as Choice has been Qantas’s COVID-19 flight credits scheme, which Choice branded as “unfair and unworkable”, accusing the airline of making customers jump through hoops to claim credit flights only to face inflated prices or the expiry of the credits altogether.

Despite Joyce’s claim that “you get the exact same as what you’ve paid for”, customers who had cancelled their flights and tried to rebook using credit found themselves having to pay more than their original ticket prices, leading to accusations of gouging on Qantas’s part.

Joyce’s perception in the public eye were not helped, either, by the airline posting a record $1.4 billion half-year profit in the six months to December 2022, at a time when ticket prices were around 20 per cent higher than 2021 levels, and following a year of strident complaints about flight cancellations, baggage mishaps and other customer-service blunders – or by the revelation that he had received $4 million in stock bonuses on top of his $2 million salary for the year.

As a result of all these snafus, Qantas-related contacts to the ACCC hit 1,700 in the 2022 financial year – up a massive 68 per cent over the year prior. “Qantas’ customer service issues, in particular long call wait times, have been well reported in the media. As Australia’s largest airline, and an airline that generally charges a premium to fly, consumers expect a better service,” the watchdog said in a scathing press release.

Joyce v the future

There’s little doubt Vanessa Hudson ascending to CEO of Qantas six months from now will mark the end of an era, with the incoming boss being afforded something of a fresh start – the unions have already extended olive branches to her in the hopes that she will prove a more agreeable presence at the negotiating table than Joyce.
Of course, once Hudson takes over, she will become the first female CEO the Flying Kangaroo has had, in a win for diversity – a win, it must be said, that echoes Joyce’s own ascendancy as an openly gay man 15 years ago.

Let us not forget that one more enemy he made was the anti-gay lobby when he threw his full-throated support (including a personal $1 million donation) behind the Yes campaign for same-sex marriage in 2017, earning him both a recognition in the Queen’s Birthday honours and a pie in the face from a disgruntled No supporter. The impact Joyce had on the ultimate victory for marriage equality is difficult to quantify – but it’s hard to understate the PR boost from the support of one of the country’s most powerful CEOs.

In the end, the legacy Alan Joyce leaves behind at Qantas is a complicated one, with the remnants of past battles strewn in his wake. If nothing else, however, he found at least one battle that truly was worth fighting.

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.

You need to be a member to post comments. Become a member today!
Momentum Media Logo
Most Innovative Company
Copyright © 2007-2026 MOMENTUMMEDIA