Alliance Airlines CEO Lee Schofield in front of a Fokker F100. (Source: Alliance Airlines)
Alliance Airlines CEO Lee Schofield in front of a Fokker F100. (Source: Alliance Airlines)
Feast Not Famine: How the Downturn proved a Boon for Charter Airlines
Haphazard schedules. Unpredictable restrictions. Social distancing. Here’s how the same conditions that brought the aviation industry to its knees in 2020 allowed charter to flourish
‘Groups that have seen the benefits of being on charter will see those work in the long term’
Much like the rest of the year, May wasn’t a particularly good time to be an employee in the aviation sector. French manufacturing giant Airbus announced cuts of 10,000 to its workforce, Anglo-German travel firm Tui said it would be axing 8,000 jobs, and Ryanair laid out plans to scrap 3,000. Back home, Qantas staff were more likely than not to be left in limbo – while, needless to say, those at Virgin Australia certainly were.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
And yet at the tail end of May, one Brisbane-based charter company was dishing out bonuses to most of its staff; reflecting the fact it was one of a handful of airlines to stay in the green over the course of the pandemic. Months on, it’s trading at a record high. To find out why, Australian Aviation spoke with Alliance Airlines chief executive Lee Schofield.
As the coronavirus pandemic continues to roil the aviation industry, several niches have emerged relatively unscathed. Though the trans-Pacific freight market might have shed nearly a third of its net volume across February/March, increased demand for PPE and other medical equipment (as well as an associated uptick in load factors) has seen it climb back towards a reset, even as regular commercial operations continue to struggle.
But for charter, it’s been a whole different story.
The unmatched ability of the private aviation sector to respond to ever-shifting border and social distancing restrictions has seen it thrive, rather than simply survive. With nearly two-thirds of the world’s aircraft grounded and inelastic demand for particular routes higher than ever, the sector has largely moved to plug this gap. The Australian government has pushed citizens stranded overseas in countries like Bolivia and India – where commercial aviation has ground to a halt in entirety – towards charter as a last resort. And at home, smaller charter operators have allowed regional industry to keep ticking over despite a drop-off in regional offerings from Qantas, Virgin and Rex.
According to Schofield, it’s marked a “shift in aviation history”.
“Groups that have seen the benefits of being on charter will see those work in the long term,” he says. Because the company has been able to modify its Fokker fleet specifically to fit customers’ needs, Schofield hopes to see new clientele stick around long term.
Social distancing in the sky
“We’re a product of our client,” Schofield proudly declares.
In a broad sense, this is true for all charter airlines – a point Alliance knows well. But clients in the resources sector, which make up the bulk of the company’s long-term customer base, have a very different set of requirements to leisure or business charter groups. Health concerns have long been paramount for mining companies operating a fly-in, fly-out roster; after all, it takes just one sick staff member to hold up a multimillion-dollar project. While it may make sense, moreover, for these firms to opt for 80-100-seater aircraft over a Qantaslink A320, Schofield says that there’s a lot more to it than that.
Increased profits
In a statement released to the ASX in mid-May, Alliance said it expects pre-tax profits to increase in 2020, up to $40 million from $32.8 million the year prior.
His company has upped cleaning regimes, increased airflow rate, and implemented temperature testing before passengers board. Depending on the route, the latter may or may not be available on commercial options. But the main trick Alliance has up its sleeve? A spaced-out seating plan.
Holding off decline
US-based market research firm IBISWorld estimates the revenue generated by Australian non-scheduled air transport will decline by just 6.1 per cent in 2019-20. Australian aviation industry revenue is slated to contract by 24.3 per cent (domestically) and 32.0 per cent (internationally) overall.
Asked about the factors that have contributed to the success of charter over the course of the crisis, Schofield answers that “the initial response to COVID in many cases was social distancing on aircraft”. A far cry from the blocked middle-seats and plexiglass screens you might see in cattle-class today, Alliance is able to offer a tailored seating arrangement, adjusted to fit the number of passengers onboard. While some (including the WHO) may argue the risk of catching a communicable disease on an aircraft fitted with commercial-grade HEPA filters is low, others would say that the peace of mind associated with such an arrangement is well worth the cost.
“Obviously the advantage that charter brings is knowing exactly who’s onboard,” Schofield adds. Moreover, many of the key FIFO operators, including Perth-based Maroomba Airlines, now require all travellers to complete pre-check-in health declaration forms or checks.
Alliance is not alone in offering social distancing in the sky, yet it’s an example that proves illustrative of why so many like-minded carriers around the world have done well over the course of the crisis. For the well-heeled, fixed-base operators (FBOs) are like “private terminals which allow passengers to skip the main airport, drive up to an entrance and walk from the tarmac straight onto their plane”. So says Alex Wilcox, CEO of US-based private airline JSX, adding that FBOs are “crowd-free places that allow people to avoid the main terminal and all the hassles and herding associated with that experience”. And on the flipside, the burgeoning “air ambulance” industry is able to offer specialised repatriation services to those who are already sick, staffed with experienced flight doctors.
‘Obviously the advantage that charter brings is knowing exactly who’s onboard’
Eleventh-hour changes
Social distancing aside, Schofield says that charter has been “agile and reactive” in ways scheduled aviation simply can’t, providing solutions to problems caused by shifting border restrictions and airline schedules.
“The private charter industry is able to operate last-minute flights within what’s operationally possible,” he tells Australian Aviation. “Charter can react immediately when travel restrictions are lifted or changed – something we are watching very closely.”
Early on in the crisis, this was most evident in continental Europe. In the days following Italy’s surprise lockdown of its northern Lombardy region, foreign residents were left scrambling to secure a seat on flights out of southern hubs like Rome Fiumicino and Naples. With commercial options limited, those with the means to do so turned to charter – with many looking for slots over the following 24-48 hours. At the time, one CEO of a US-based charter operator told international media that his company was receiving as many as 1,000 new flight requests per day for evacuation out of areas such as Milan.
‘Charter can react immediately when travel restrictions are lifted or changed – something we are watching very closely’
Back home, the situation has been similar, driven by fickle federal and interstate travel restrictions. Media magnate Kerry Stokes was able to skirt WA’s notoriously strict hotel quarantine requirements in April, after making the dash from Aspen to Perth aboard a privately chartered Bombardier BD-700. And while Australian backpackers trapped in rural India might not have received the same red-carpet treatment, many of them were nevertheless able to hightail it home even after all international and domestic airline services ground to a halt in the country.
Also playing into the popularity of charter in recent months has been the complexity of obtaining refunds from the major airlines. With Qantas’ COVID refunds policy set to come under the legal microscope as a result of a class action brought by law firm Slater & Gordon, it’s clear that the convenience and security of large-scale group bookings may well be another factor tipping the scales in favour of charter for many resource operators.
Hybrid service
On the back of a full-capacity aircraft operating certificate (AOC) dated to April, Alliance operates a number of joint public-private scheduled services.
Bright horizons for Alliance’s network
From the tone of Schofield’s voice, you can tell that he is one of the few airline executives to see the light at the end of the tunnel. Perhaps he’s looking forward to taking delivery of 14 Embraer E190 jets from September, thanks in part to an equity raise that injected $122 million into company coffers.
Yet maybe it’s because he knows all too well that, in Australia, the charter business model is watertight. The day of this interview, Alliance just happened to be launching its inaugural service linking the tourist hotspot of Cairns with Maroochydore, on Queensland’s Sunshine Coast. Elsewhere in the world, the timing might have raised eyebrows – but in Australia, governed by the tyranny of distance, it’s so natural that it has been subsidised by the state government. And it was for that reason that weeks earlier, the company added its much-hyped Brisbane-Moranbah route, connecting the state’s capital with one of its youngest towns.
At the start of June, the airline picked up another subsidised route, cutting a deal with the Palaszczuk government to ferry Queenslanders from Brisbane to the Whitsundays. Though details of the agreement remained largely unspecified, it was tipped to create more than 85 jobs for the Whitsundays’ economy.
Great news indeed for the wilting local tourism sector – but it’s a fair bet they won’t be dishing out bonuses anytime soon.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.