Virgin Australia line up at Melbourne’s Tullamarine at the start of the pandemic. (Victor Pody)
Virgin Australia line up at Melbourne’s Tullamarine at the start of the pandemic. (Victor Pody)
Is Virgin Doomed to be a Repeat Offender?
The airline has taken its biggest gamble – and not changed that much
On 25 June, Qantas announced it was to make 6,000 employees, or around 20 per cent of its workforce, redundant. The numbers didn’t come as much of a surprise but unions were, predictably, livid. Shortly after the business revealed the plans to the ASX, the TWU pinged a statement into my inbox, with national secretary Michael Kaine seething. “The Qantas CEO is very good at walking the halls of Canberra when it suits his agenda, yet he is quick to cut jobs and hang workers out to dry,” he said, before adding the business should have held firm on the cuts until a decision on extending JobKeeper was reached. “Qantas is now making hasty decisions to slash jobs, which will affect thousands of families.”
Fast forward six weeks, and Virgin Australia made a similar announcement. This time though, the airline was to cut one-third of all employees – 3,000 – and cut the Tigerair brand altogether. Not only was this a considerably higher percentage than its arch-rival, but the decision was taken after the government had moved to extend JobKeeper, thereby making it possible to keep workers on paid stand-down. This time, when the TWU email hits my inbox, not a bad word was uttered towards chief executive Paul Scurrah or Virgin’s likely new owners, Bain Capital. In fact, quite incredibly, they called the announcement “difficult” but “broadly positive”. So, what’s different?
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
The answer is that, behind the scenes, unions were for months lobbying furiously to stop Virgin Australia regressing back to its Virgin Blue, low-cost routes, and it’s a battle they unequivocally won. “Virgin Australia aims to be the best value carrier in the market, not a low-cost carrier,” said the statement announcing the job losses. It added that long-haul international flying would remain an “important part of the plan” after COVID-19 and that domestic lounges and business class would remain.
And that move – which came against the tide of speculation – indeed saved thousands of jobs. But the problem is, will it ultimately save the business? Virgin will be slimmed down, for sure, but it will be operating in largely the same space it was fighting in during the last 10 years. So one-sided was the beating at Qantas’ hands that, when Virgin finally whimpered into administration, its debt ballooned to an eye-popping $7 billion. Even chief executive Scurrah will remain – though he was, to be fair, relatively new to the role.
Compare this with the success story of Virgin Blue. That business launched in August 2000 with just 200 staff and two aircraft, but low-ticket prices and bundles of Branson bravado saw it quickly race to be valued at $2 billion. Its real secret – obvious now, of course, but a gamble at the time – was on shamelessly copying the no-frills revolution erupting in Europe and the US and applying it to the Aussie domestic market. Back in the early days, it flew just one type of aircraft, the 737-700 and -800 series, and hammered down turnaround times to just 30 minutes. Less time in the air meant less wastage on the ground. A then-lumbering Qantas, frankly, never saw it coming.
But as it grew, it moved further away from its no-frills strategy, as Blue became Australia. Fashion darling Juli Grbac designed the red uniforms, superstar chef Luke Mangan rustled up the menu, swanky lounges popped up and business class launched on domestic routes. The so-called ‘capacity wars’ saw Virgin become infatuated with becoming an equal to Qantas, at the expense of profitability. Just as its rival was quietly doing the opposite. In 2015, Virgin Australia took its share in the now defunct Tigerair from 60 to 100 per cent to challenge Jetstar, but at that point, things had started to get out of hand, as the cocky youngster morphed into stodgy veteran and became set in its ways.
In a June Four Corners documentary, current Virgin chair Elizabeth Bryan attacked former chief executive John Borghetti – the man behind the switch – and withered that he didn’t know how to run a “good enough business”. Borghetti, though, dug in. “Virgin had found itself placed in the middle between Jetstar and Qantas and it had outgrown the low-cost space but hadn’t quite penetrated the corporate space, so you needed to go one way or the other,” he explained. “You couldn’t go back to the basic low-cost carrier phase because your cost base was too high, so you only had one way to go and that was to attack Qantas and get the corporate market.” For all the flack he took, it seems Bain has come to largely the same conclusion.
Except, there are some crucial differences. Virgin 2.0 is being billed as a hybrid – and it will be, for sure – but it’s also more like a home with room for an extension. As the initial wave of coronavirus – we hope – fades with a vaccine in the next six months, Virgin will relaunch as a far nimbler airline. But, crucially, it will have the potential to rapidly expand if needs be. And that flexibility could well be key to its resurgence. If video conference apps such as Zoom destroy Qantas’ lucrative business market, and the international borders remain slammed shut, an airline primed for budget interstate holidays could succeed as Qantas stumbles. But, if things open quicker, Virgin has the flexibility to pick and choose its long-haul battles depending on which countries recover quickest.
One crucial point not reported much by the mainstream media was Scurrah’s promise that he would leave the door open for some of those redundant staff to return in a few years. The point is that the business’ good relationship with the staff – and the unions – means they are more likely to return than you think.
It certainly won’t please Alan Joyce. Like him or loathe him, the Qantas boss knows exactly how to play the media, and, in early August, knew exactly what he wanted from Virgin 2.0. He told veteran interviewer Kerry O’Brien at Griffith University his rival would likely “head back downmarket to where Virgin Blue was”.
“That will give Qantas more opportunities,” he added. “We’re already finding in places like Hamilton Island and Maroochydore, the dynamic has changed, and I think it will change even more when Virgin comes out of administration.”
But for now, Virgin has the higher ground – by keeping everyone else guessing.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.