Lady Southern Cross outside the Kingsford Smith Air Service hangar in Mascot, 1934. (Mitchell Library, State Library of New South Wales)

The final flight of Kingsford Smith

He was arguably Australia’s greatest-ever aviator, and the namesake of Sydney Airport – but 90 years after he and co-pilot Tommy Pethybridge vanished over the Andaman Sea, the fate of Sir Charles Kingsford Smith has largely remained a mystery. Now, Australian explorer Damien Lay believes he has found the wreckage of Kingsford Smith’s plane, the Lady Southern Cross, and spoke to Australian Aviation about his discovery – and Smithy’s legacy.

Editor’s note: This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

AA: Can you tell us a bit about Sir Charles Kingsford Smith and how important he is to Australia’s aviation history?

This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
Login
Become a Member
To continue reading the rest of this article, please login.

or

To unlock all Australian Aviation magazine content and again unlimited access to our daily news and features, become a member today!
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
PRINT
$49.95 for 1 year Become a Member
See benefits
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
PRINT + DIGITAL
$99.95 for 1 year Become a Member
$179.95 for 2 years Become a Member
See benefits
  • Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
  • Access to the Australian Aviation app
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
  • Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
  • Daily news updates via our email bulletin
DIGITAL
$5.99 Monthly Become a Member
$59.95 Annual Become a Member
See benefits
  • Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
  • Access to the Australian Aviation app
  • Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
  • Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
  • Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
  • Daily news updates via our email bulletin

DL: I genuinely believe that Sir Charles Kingsford Smith is the greatest pilot to have ever flown. He holds more flight records than any other man or woman, even in today’s terms; his accomplishments and achievements in aviation were extraordinary in a very, very short period, and he certainly propelled and advanced aviation by probably 10 years during the late 1920s and early 1930s.

His biggest feat was probably the 1928 crossing of the Pacific Ocean from the US to Australia, the first man to ever do so. And in 1928, that was, I guess, the equivalent of trying to fly to the moon, or put a man on the moon. The distance was so vast. The technology at the time was certainly not of the standard it is today, and to navigate that vast distance was just an extraordinary feat in aviation. He then went on, seven years later, to conduct the second crossing of the Pacific Ocean from Australia to America, and in those seven years, nobody had made that crossing again.

So, in a very, very short period of time, he pulled off two of the most daring flights in aviation history. He was also the first man to circumnavigate the globe by air; he set so many records for not only speed, but distance – from England to Australia, the first man to cross the Tasman from Australia to New Zealand, and again from New Zealand to Australia. His involvement in the development of aviation – not only just his records and accomplishments, but his involvement in safety, developing airports or airfields around Australia and New Zealand and other parts of the world in his time – really did advance aviation and demonstrated the capability or the value of aviation as it pushed forward into a commercialised world.

His final flight was from England to Australia. It was an attempt to recapture the speed record from England, but the flight was actually more to get home to his young son, who was about to turn three. Smithy, at the time, was stuck in England with no way home other than to fly, which he chose to do, probably against his better judgement, but that was the only option that he had. It was on that flight he was last sighted in Myanmar or Burma, by aviation authorities there, failed to arrive in Singapore the next day and was never seen again.

AA: What’s the current theory of what happened?

DL: Over the past 90 years, there have been many theories that have emerged, some based on very kind of loose evidence, and some based on very, very strong evidence. The flight that he was on, as he left Yangon, he was crossing the Gulf of Martaban, heading to the west coast of Myanmar, so over the Gulf, and certainly the strongest theory that I followed was developed by a gentleman by the name of Jack Hodder. Jack Hodder was working in Myanmar, or Burma at the time, for a tin dredging company when, 18 months after Kingsford Smith’s and Tommy Pethybridge’s disappearance, a wheel from the aircraft was found floating near an island known as Aye Island by a local fisherman. Jack Hodder, an Australian pilot, aviation engineer, and extraordinary man, was one of the very first people to examine the wheel and confirmed that it was from the Lady Southern Cross, the aircraft they disappeared in.

From that moment, a theory developed that they potentially crashed into Aye Island on this flight. The island itself is about two miles off the coast of Burma. It’s 480 feet high. So it was theorised that as Sir Charles and Tommy Pethybridge approached the coastline of Burma, they dropped down to 500 feet. The island itself is quite fascinating. It was uncharted at the time. It’s only a small island –about a mile long and half a mile wide – and Jack Hodder conducted an extensive search. He located three other pieces of the aircraft on the island’s foreshore: two pieces of duralium and one piece of extruded aluminium, which he believed was from the cockpit.

So, his theory developed that potentially they’d collided with this island that they didn’t know was there. It was approximately, let’s say, three in the morning. It was a clear night, but still in the darkness, perhaps the island was not visible to them. That theory was a very, very good theory, based on the evidence that existed at the time and the work that Jack Hodder had done, but there were still some unanswered questions. He dragged in the bay of the island with hooks to see if he could locate the aircraft, because he believed that it may be in the water surrounding the island, unsuccessfully. So then that theory really kind of stuck as the most well-supported theory.

It was another gentleman, Ted Wickstead, who was probably our greatest Australian aviation historian, who spent about 50 years researching and working off the back of Jack’s theory, and uncovered more evidence to support it. The problem was that the island itself was about one degree off where it actually was located on the maps, and it wasn’t until Ted put the island in the correct position that it put it directly in Smithy’s flight path. So, Ted conducted three expeditions during the late 70s and early 80s, and again, more data, more evidence emerged from his efforts – yet the plane was still not located. Ted passed away in 2001, and then in 2005, I continued on from Jack’s work through Ted’s work, and then conducted 20 years of my own research and investigation into their disappearance.

AA: What are your thoughts on the theory?

DL: What we did notice when we were there is an enormous population of fruit bats – the big fruit bats, like we have in Sydney – that live on the summit of the island. And when you stir those bats up, we’re talking thousands of bats flying up into the air in essentially a giant column. What I believed was that as they approached the island, which was directly in their flight path. Those bats were stirred, shot up in front of the aircraft, and the initial incident was a bat strike. And then, what we did notice was, through our work, that there is an enormous sandbar that runs off the back of the island. What we believe is that the bat strike obviously caused the aircraft significant damage, which also explains the location of the debris that Jack Hodder found back in the 1930s.

So, I do believe that Charles and Tommy were able to set the aircraft down on this sandbar, which is a huge sandbar – I mean, you could almost land a jumbo jet on this thing at low tide – and they were probably a little bit confused, given the island wasn’t on their chart, so they didn’t know that it was there, potentially confused by the fact that they might have been landing on a beach when they were actually landing on a sandbar at low tide. It would have been very disorienting until they managed to assess that situation. And then I do believe that, once realising that they were on a sandbar and the tide was coming in, they would have been unable to swim to the island from their location, and really left with the only option being to try and take off again.

It was in that take-off that I believe they’ve actually collided with the western headland of Aye Island, which would have been directly in their flight path, that’s caused damage that’s evident to the undercarriage that was recovered. I believe what’s happened then is that they’ve tried to conduct a water-based landing. The undercarriage did not retract for that landing, and as they’ve made contact with the water, the undercarriage that was stuck down has bitten into the water, causing the aircraft to flip over upside-down and then sink to the bottom in what would have been a very, very strong impact, based on the wreckage that we’re seeing in the sonar image.

AA: You conducted your own expeditions starting in 2005 – what methods did you use?

DL: The advantage that we had on that first expedition was the ability to apply technology to the search effort. So, we searched an enormous amount of the ocean and waters surrounding Aye Island by sonar, and anything that we found on the bottom of the ocean we would put a diver onto. In that two-week operation, we had five days on location, so we essentially worked 24 hours a day, sonaring and diving on any suspicious target or object.

Back in 1980, when Ted was conducting his search, all he could do was a physical search of the sea floor using divers, which is a very slow, laborious process when you have such a big area to cover. Our greatest advantage was sonar, and that was initially how we located the aircraft in 2009. The diving itself, you are in what’s called black water, so you’re completely blind. On the bottom, when you’re diving, you can’t see your gauges. You’ve got no communication to the surface, and the aircraft itself is in 100 feet of water. So, you’re at a significant depth, literally diving in the middle of nowhere.

And then, of course, three times a day you get six- to eight-knot currents that run through, and as soon as those currents pick up, it becomes exceptionally dangerous. You just cannot see what you’re doing on the bottom. The ability to just swim into a hazard is very real and exists, and if you do have an issue on the bottom, you’re completely blind, so the ability to figure out what that problem is presents an enormous challenge. So, it’s exceptionally dangerous work. There’s no helicopter evacuation. There are no hospitals nearby if anything goes wrong. So, a very, very difficult process, but it was a process that you just had to kind of stick at and keep doing over and over again until you got the results that you were looking for.

AA: And what did you find? Are you sure it’s the Lady Southern Cross?

DL: The sonar image that we collected gives us an extraordinary picture of the aircraft. The aircraft is upside down on the sea floor. It’s sitting on a mud bottom, and the aircraft itself is relatively intact. The engine has been ejected from the front of the aircraft, and I would assume that occurred during the impact, with the engine ripping away. The aircraft was made of timber, so all the support for the engine had pulled away from the aircraft. But the engine is only about a metre and a half, two metres from the actual front of the aircraft, so we believed it was still attached by control cables. That paints a very, very good picture. The measurements all correspond; we can see the engine and the propeller in the sonar image. So, that gave us a very, very good indicator that we’d located it.The material that we recovered from the aircraft is extremely corroded, so the condition is not very good at all. You wouldn’t picture an aircraft; you would picture more the remains, almost like a fossil or a skeleton. It’s very much covered in growth, but we managed to recover a number of steel components that all correspond with the aircraft itself – nothing that absolutely identifies the aircraft. We recovered copper fuel lines, which are actually very well preserved. Most of the aluminium has gone. We can see in the sonar image what we believe is the other wheel, et cetera, and we recovered timber. So, all of the items that we recovered certainly support this being the Lady Southern Cross, but it’s when we put together all of the circumstantial evidence that’s been collected over the 90 years that I really get to a point where this can be nothing else, which is a great place to be.

I’m 100 per cent certain that we’ve located the Lady Southern Cross. There is not a single doubt in my mind at all. The challenge is that in black water, I can’t take photographs. I can’t film it. I can’t show it to people, other than the material we’ve recovered. But everybody that’s worked on the project, that’s either been on expedition with us or researched in the background for me, there’s nothing at all to say that this is not the Lady Southern Cross, and I do believe that the remains of the two men would still be on board – things like potentially leather boots or wrist watches, flying goggles, flying helmets, leather and things like that would be very well preserved in this location – but one of the other challenges that we have when we’re diving is the mud bottom. Sometimes we’ve been there, we’ve dived on the location, and the actual aircraft was like a metre under the mud, and other times we’ve been there, it’s been slightly exposed. The mud in that area moves around quite constantly, so it’s difficult work when you’re blindfolded, trying to dig through the mud to recover components, and you don’t really even know what you’re kind of working on when you’re down there.

AA: Besides Sydney Airport being named after Kingsford Smith, what impact did he and his disappearance have on Australian aviation?

Their disappearance at the time sparked one of the biggest air and sea searches in history, back in 1935. Following on, Kingsford Smith was such a strong advocate for the use of American aircraft in Australian aviation. That advocacy was based on the fact that the Americans were building aircraft more suited to our climate here in Australia, so aircraft that could fly further were more capable of dealing with the climate conditions here, the heat, the cold, et cetera. We do have a very similar climate to North America, whereas the British aircraft were designed for much colder climates, shorter distances, and so on.

Kingsford Smith saw that, and saw that we were losing many, many great pilots as a result of aircraft not being designed and built for the conditions in Australia. That didn’t resonate very well with the government – we were still very much part of the Commonwealth at that time, so to go against the Commonwealth was not well-favoured in the eyes of the government. After his disappearance, that certainly changed. They lifted the ban on the importation of American aircraft into Australia, and that in itself really helped drive Australian aviation forward.

AA: Do you think Smithy’s story has fallen by the wayside in the intervening decades?

DL: I do, and I don’t think it’s an uncommon kind of theme that occurs in Australia, and it’s an interesting contrast with America. America does such a wonderful job of maintaining the memory of its historical figures and acknowledging the great achievements that have been made by Americans throughout the centuries, but certainly in Australia, I do think a lot of our historical figures are being lost to time, and I think that’s generational. You talk to older generations, and they know who Charles Kingsford Smith is; you talk to younger generations, and they wouldn’t even know Sydney Airport is named after him or who he was.

I think that’s quite a normal thing – I don’t look at it as something that we do intentionally, I think it’s just the natural course of time – but it’s important that we do continue to remember all our great people in Australian history who have achieved so much. Don Bradman is another one, for instance; rarely do we hear his name anymore. So, it does happen, and it’s sad, but that’s why we do things like this, to kind of bring back their memory and remind people and continue to share all of our wonderful stories.

I think it is a beautiful story. It is a story that should not be forgotten. His contribution to aviation, especially, was extraordinary. In the late 1920s, he was probably one of the most famous men on the planet, and he was extremely well-known throughout the world. I do think it’s important that we continue to introduce these stories to new generations and to people who may not be as familiar with them.

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.

You need to be a member to post comments. Become a member today!
Momentum Media Logo
Most Innovative Company
Copyright © 2007-2026 MOMENTUMMEDIA