Pilot experience and licensing is a real problem, particularly for the smaller operators. KEITH TONKIN
2020 and a new decade
Time to look back
2020 and the new decade is here. With that in mind it is a good time to look back on a few things of interest that have happened in the last ten years.
For many years there has been discussion about the impending pilot shortage. Well we seem to now have a real situation where there is an expanding airline system of low-cost carriers and yes there is increased demand for pilots. But not just rookie pilots. A few recent airline accidents have the right seater being a very low time pilot and little or no help and even a hindrance to the captain when needed. What is needed is new pilots but with experience. It is all very well for airlines to say that they are running their own flight schools (at the expense of the trainee!) but they will still end up with a guy or gal with maybe 150-200 hours. Kindergarten experience.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
Airlines would much prefer to have new pilots with real experience who they can bring to their airline. They want people who have real commercial experience. That can be had via way of the Australian GA system but does not include having gotten bulk flight time in a baby plane, like an RAAus aircraft.
Part 61 regulations. What a subject. As with all new regulations we were told that the new regs would just be a compilation of existing regulations and that they would be good for the industry and prevent accidents. No. The Part 61 regulations and the coupled Manual of Standards blew out to thousands of pages, enough to choke a horse. And who pays for the average pilot to wade through all this. Remember it is written in legal speak not user-friendly understandable language. Even CASA staff members have issues with reading their own regulations. Two CASA staff members can read a regulation two ways. So how is the person in the field supposed to read and comply with those same regulations? The re-writing of the regulations has been running for over 30 years. One can only say that the regulator is deficient in not giving industry the new regulations in a confined space of time.
A check of the CASA annual report for 2018-2019 shows that since Part 61 was introduced accidents initially decreased but are now back to 2015 levels. Incidents since 2015 decreased but are now above 2015 levels. Part 61 is a major disaster for aviation, GA in particular. It was meant to get rid of exemptions, but we are now past 300 exemptions with more to come.
Another area of the problems that Part 61 created is that of flight instructors. Now a person can come into the system with zero experience. He or she gets a PPL then a CPL. They can then go on to get an instructor’s ticket with as little as 200 hours and start teaching. The blind leading the blind. Maybe a new instructor should have something like 400 hours before becoming an instructor. Experience to pass on. So the new Grade 3 builds up time and may rise to become a Grade 2. Then they may branch out and go to an airline or even an overseas airline. The bigger salary is understandably appealing. There is little incentive to become a Grade 1 due to the extra upgrade cost, little additional financial return and extra responsibilities. That then leaves a void of Grade 1 instructors who, in the past, would have become Chief Flying Instructors now called Head of Operations or HOOs. Those HOOs would then become ATOs or Flight Examiners. From the good HOOs CASA would then get people to become CASA staff.
With the drying up of HOOs CASA is having a real problem with getting suitable staff and that in turn is reflected in the interface of CASA and industry. One could view all that as saying CASA shot itself in the foot. The industry is crying out for experienced Grade 1 instructors. People with experience to pass on. People who could hold the line and set the standards. People who can eventually become CASA staff.
Over the past few years there has been a constant critism of CASA, for many and various reasons. Reading publications from the UK, Canada, New Zealand and America I do not see local aviation industry participants in constant criticism of their regulators. Surely this says that there is an issue or issues that need to be addressed. As that expression goes “Where there is smoke there is fire.”
On the subject of CASA it should have offices at all secondary airports to be in contact with the very industry that it purports to regulate. Instead we have the bean counters congregating the airline and GA guys in a city office at arms length from the industry. Them and us as some would say. I am sure that the GA industry at large would agree that CASA should have a new paragraph in its charter that says ‘Must support and promote aviation’.
‘The Part 61 regulations and the coupled Manual of Standards blew out to thousands of pages, enough to choke a horse’
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.