Fleet defender
HMAS Hobart commissioning marks new era for Navy’s air defence abilities
With its awesome SPY-1D(V) radar, Aegis combat system and capability to fire SM-2 and ESSM missiles, and eventually SM-3 and SM-6, HMAS Hobart, the Navy’s newest warship, possesses a world-class air defence capability.
Eventually there will be three such vessels, when NUSHIPs Brisbane and Sydney enter service.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
And further down the track there will be nine Future Frigates, configured for anti-submarine warfare but with very significant air defences.
The government hasn’t yet decided on which of three frigate designs but it has specified their key sensor fit – an evolution of the successful Australian CEA phased array radar, Aegis and an Australian tactical interface based around the proven Saab 9LV combat system.
Eventually, more than two decades out, Australia will possess a truly formidable Navy, comprising a dozen advanced surface combatant, a dozen subs, new support and patrol vessels, all networked with RAAF F-35s, Growlers, P-8A Poseidon, Wedgetails and Tritons.
Eventually, Australia will possess a truly formidable Navy.
But right now, there’s just one, HMAS Hobart, and she won’t be deemed fully operational until she’s completed further comprehensive trials, around the end of next year.
HMAS Hobart was commissioned on September 23, a happy occasion on which the numerous problems of the air warfare destroyer (AWD) project did not seem the big deal they once were.
The reality is that HMAS Hobart is 30-months later than originally planned, with the whole program now costing $9.12 billion, a blowout of around $1.2 billion.
On the current schedule, ship two will be delivered in July 2018 and ship three in December 2019.
Although the vessels were referred to as AWDs throughout the construction, the Navy now refers to them as DDGs, the internationally accepted and more accurate term for Guided Missile Destroyer. HMAS Hobart is DDG 39, Brisbane will be DDG 41 and Sydney DDG 42.
The AWD program was launched in the mid-2000s, though as far back as the early 1990s the need for modern air defence warships was recognised.
At one time it was even considered building an extra six Anzacs configured for air warfare but that idea was quickly shelved as they were simply too small.
The 2000 Defence White Paper said the navy needed a long range air defence capability which had diminished with retirement of the last of the Perth-class DDGs and was not adequately replaced by the Adelaide-class guided missile frigates (FFGs) and the new Anzac frigates (FFHs).
It said the FFGs would be replaced by at least three larger and more capable air defence ships, preferably built in Australia. As planning proceeded, the Navy concluded there was only one possible combat system for the new vessels – Aegis.
In mid-2007, the government announced the winner was Spanish shipbuilder Navantia with its Alvaro de Bazan-class F-100 frigate, substantially cheaper and likely to arrive years sooner than the new and larger US design the Navy preferred.
The long delay produced one particular consequence which is now looming larger. Even before vessel one achieves initial operational capability, a very expensive upgrade has been planned for all three, under project SEA 4000 Phase 6.
The Defence Integrated Investment Program says that will be run over the period 2017-28 at a cost of $4-5 billion.
Back when Defence chose Aegis and the SPY radar, it understandably opted for the latest version which then was Aegis Baseline 7. Technically that’s now Aegis Baseline 7.1 Refresh 2.
On Australian ships Aegis, with the SPY-1D(V) radar and AN/SPQ-9B horizon search radar, it’s actually closer to the US baseline 8.
However, Aegis Baseline 9 is now being installed on new US warships and retrofitted to some older vessels.
Australian Strategic Policy Institute analyst James Mugg noted that Australia’s AWDs had taken longer to build than the Aegis system has taken to evolve.
“Current plans have the AWDs being delivered with an earlier generation Aegis system than new-build American ships, then being taken offline for an expensive upgrade less than a decade after delivery,” he wrote.
Baseline 9 offers some significant advantages.
It’s open architecture, it has expanded capability for dealing with multiple simultaneous threats and, with appropriate additional modules, the headline-grabbing capability to knock down ballistic missiles.
With North Korean sabre-rattling, this was a big deal for Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull when he announced the Future Frigates would get Aegis.
“This decision will maximise the Future Frigate’s air warfare capabilities, enabling those ships to engage threat missiles at long range. A number of states, notably of course, North Korea, are developing missiles with advanced range and speed. We must have the capability to meet and defeat them,” he said at the Pacific 2017 maritime exhibition in Sydney.
Future Frigates will certainly adopt an evolution of Baseline 9, or its successor.
BMD capability is as much as a decade away and for all the speculation about North Korean nukes, the far more likely threat right now comes from a growing diversity of ever more capable aircraft and missiles.
The Hobarts would provide the air defences on any deployed Australian task group. They could readily play a role in any US-led coalition operation, for example if conflict with North Korea looms large.
But well before HMAS Hobart goes anywhere it could encounter such threats, the ship and its 186 crewmen and women have lots of work.
Hobart’s inaugural commanding officer, Captain John Stavridis, said the more time spent operating the platform and understanding Aegis, the more we realise how capable this ship is.
“It is an outstanding ship; that’s not to talk down our current surface combatants but rather a reflection of what this new capability brings,” he said.
It is an outstanding ship… a reflection of what this new capability brings. Capt John Stavridis
Hobart sailed through initial builder trials with few of the anticipated first-of-type problems. That was one positive consequence of the long delay.
“What the extensive schedule slippage has done is meant people have become very well informed about their systems and how they should work. Prior to sailing we understood the systems much better than in a program that maybe had been done much quicker,” said AWD program manager Commodore Craig Bourke.
Stavridis said Navy Operational Test and Evaluation (NOTE) trials were next, covering first of class platform trials, integration of the MH-60R (Romeo) helicopter, gunnery and more.
That culminates with the big one, the US Navy combat system ship qualification trials (CSSQT, pronounced sea-squat) conducted on the instrumented range off the US west coast.
“We will deploy to the US to facilitate system grooming and conduct further training in order to prove every aspect of the Aegis Weapon System,” he said. That will involve live firing of missiles.
“It will put us and our ship to the test. We will of course conduct a significant amount of team training well before that period. That’s already started.”
“When we pass those serials and prove ourselves and Aegis, our Chief will be able to recommend IOC to government. That is the milestone which means Hobart is ready for operations.”
Even before that, HMAS Hobart has been ranked number five on the list of the world’s 10 deadliest destroyers on the Defencyclopaedia website.
“It is estimated that three Hobarts equipped with SM-6 missiles would be able to provide adequate air defence against threats encountered along their northern coast. This is a massive increase in capability, thanks to the advanced long-range radars and missiles on board,” it says.
Australia doesn’t yet have SM-6 in inventory but this very advanced missile will surely come.
The article ranks the South Korean King Sejong The Great-class as number one and the US Arleigh Burke-class at number two.
The Korean DDGs are very large, 11,000-tonne, extremely well-armed multi-role Aegis vessels, their capability no doubt what it is because of their petulant northern neighbour.
“A single warship of this class can obliterate the entire North Korean surface, sub-surface fleet and pound targets deep within their territory without breaking a sweat,” it says.
The Defencylopaedia article says if there’s one conclusion we can come to, it is that the US Aegis plus SPY plus Mark 41 missile vertical launch system (VLS) combination is the ideal choice for a multirole destroyer, offering exceptional flexibility, upgradability and scalability.
The Hobarts come with just that combo, with a 48-cell Mark 41 VLS, plus ESSM and SM-2 missiles for air defence. Sounds like a lot of cells but the latest Arleigh Burkes have 96.
The Raytheon ESSM (Evolves Sea Sparrow Missile) has a range around 50-kilometres with significant capability against fast sea-skimming missiles. ESSM is quad-packed in Mark 41, that is there are four missiles per cell.
Raytheon’s SM-2, with a range in excess of 150-kilometres and 24,000-metre fight ceiling is a well-proven and widely used missile, with a record of some 2700 successful live fire tests.
Raytheon has just announced it will reopen the SM-2 production line to fulfil new orders from Australia, Japan, South Korea and the Netherlands who pooled resources to make a US$650 million buy of additional missiles through the US Foreign Military Sales (FMS).
With no foreign orders, production halted in 2013 but will now resume early next year on a modernised and reconfigured line designed to increase manufacturing efficiencies.
The US FMS announcement says Australia wanted to buy up to 80 SM-2
Block IIIB missiles, up to 15 MK 97 SM-2 Block IIIB guidance sections, VLS cannisters, technical documentation and contractor support in a deal worth around US$300 million.
These are intended for anti-air warfare test firings during CSSQT for the three AWDs.
“The SM-2 Block IIIB missiles, combined with the Aegis combat systems in the AWDs, will provide significantly enhanced area defence capabilities over critical South East Asian air-and-sea-lines of communication,” the US Defense Security Cooperation Agency said in its announcement of the proposed sale.
So, does the absence of US interest in buying additional missiles means it plans to phase out SM-2 in favour of SM-3 and SM-6?
No, says Raytheon’s Thadeous Smith, who briefed reporters on SM-3 and SM-6 at Pacific 2017. It just means that the US has sufficient stocks and it doesn’t need more right now.
The US is certainly buying SM-3 and SM-6, as likely will Australia, eventually.
Neither is cheap – SM-3 is around US$10 million each and SM-6 a bargain at US$2.6 million – but, with the appropriate Aegis upgrades, would give Australia a deployable BMD capability. Putting that in perspective SM-2 has a nominal unit cost of US$750,000.
Right now the only SM-3 users are the US and Japan, though it is being being deployed into Romania and Poland in the NATO Missile Defence System.
SM-3 is capable of hitting short and intermediate range ballistic missiles in mid-course, that is, post-boost and before re-entry, and even satellites in low earth orbit.
SM-3 won’t yet intercept intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs), though future versions may have some limited ability.
SM-6, with a range around 150-kilometres, can hit ballistic missiles in terminal phase, as well as aircraft, sea-skimming missiles and even other warships.
This missile is especially versatile as it uses the active radar homing seeker from the AMRAAM air-to-air missile. The US Navy is buying 1800 rounds with full rate production now under way.
As HMAS Hobart trials proceed, the RAN will learn much about this new capability and its ability to operate in conjunction with other warships, ours and allies, through its Cooperative Engagement Capability, and with fifth generation aircraft such as F-35.
Already the US demonstrated this potential with a 2016 trial at the White Sands Missile Range in which a US Marine Corps F-35B detected a missile beyond the horizon.
It passed targeting data by way of its Multi-Function Advanced Data Link to the land-based USS Desert Ship, an Aegis test facility, which fired a SM-6 to intercept the target.
For all the testing and live firing of missiles, Aegis has rarely been used for real.
The first and most tragic case occurred in the Persian Gulf in July 1988 when USS Vincennes shot down an Iranian airliner in the belief that it was an attacking Iranian F-14. All 290 aboard died. Aegis worked as intended and the tragedy stemmed from human error – a failure of identification – on Vincennes.
More recently off the coast of Yemen on October 3 last year, USS Mason fired a pair of SM-2s and an ESSM and even launched its Australian-built Nulka decoys in response to a pair of anti-ship missiles fired from the coast by Houthi rebels.
It’s not entirely clear if the incoming missiles were shot down or crashed into the sea of their own accord but this was the first ever incident of ship-based missiles fired from a VLS at actual threat missiles.
Three days later USS Mason fired at two more missiles and again the result isn’t clear. US officials weren’t sure whether the first missile was shot down or just fell into the sea but said the second was shot down at a range of about 13-kilometres.
Two days later Mason fired countermeasures in response to what may have been a third missile attack.
The missile threat from the Iranian-backed Houthis was certainly real. On October 2, 2016, the fast catamaran Swift, made by Incat in Hobart and operated by the UAE, was badly damage by a missile fired from Yemen. It’s thought the culprit was a Chinese-made and widely exported C-802 anti-ship missile.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.