Out of the ashes
The lessons of BA9
The incident is so dramatic and frightening – and so relevant to today’s airlines as they grapple with how to handle volcanic ash – that it seems as if it happened only yesterday.
But it was 30 years ago on June 24 1982 that BA9, 747-236B G-BDXH City of Edinburgh, found itself flying into a wall of volcanic ash over Indonesia en route from Kuala Lumpur to Perth, catapulting Cap-tain Eric Moody to international fame.
This content is available exclusively to Australian Aviation members.
A monthly membership is only $5.99 or save with our annual plans.
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
- Unlimited access to all Australian Aviation digital content
- Access to the Australian Aviation app
- Australian Aviation quarterly print & digital magazines
- Access to In Focus reports every month on our website
- Access to our Behind the Lens photo galleries and other exclusive content
- Daily news updates via our email bulletin
A chilling address delivered so calmly by Captain Moody has become the greatest airline passenger announcement of all time: “Ladies and gentlemen, this is your Cap-tain speaking. We have a small problem. All four engines have stopped. We are doing our damnedest to get them under control. I trust you are not in too much distress. ” For the 263 passengers and crew aboard, death was only a matter of time.
Captain Moody’s famous words came some time after the British Airways 747 entered the ash cloud at 9. 40pm on a clear, moonless night.
Initially, the passengers and crew were in awe of the strange, static electrical light show but that sensation quickly turned to terror as the jet’s four engines glowed white, spurted flame and halted. The 747 had blundered into the ash cloud from the sudden eruption of Mount Galunggung. It was 9. 43pm.
Passenger Arthur Ewan described the feel-ing as “horrific. It still affects me and Shirley today. The cabin was quiet, people were pray-ing. We just hugged and held hands. ” Passengers and crew now faced an ago-nising 42 minutes before the 747 touched down safely in Jakarta.
When the incident first occurred, Cap-tain Moody was downstairs in the first class zone seeking out the toilet as the upper deck one was occupied. “Suddenly, I was summoned back to the cockpit,” he recalled to Australian Aviation.
“On the way back I noticed puffs of smoke billowing out of the floor vents and there was an acrid smell of ionized electricals. ” When he entered the flightdeck he saw an intense display of St Elmo’s Fire danc-ing across the windshields: “I had never seen anything like it, ” he said. “It’s not un-usual in high wispy cloud to see St Elmo’s Fire. But it developed into something more than we’d ever seen before. ” Captain Moody recalls he was pleased to see that his senior first officer Rich-ard Greaves and senior engineer Barry Townley-Freeman had turned on the engine igniters and seatbelt signs: “Roger pointed out through the side window the glow from the engines and then the St Emo’s fire gave way to what could only be described as tracer bullets streaming towards the cockpit. ” What worried Captain Moody more was the smoke now billowing out of the air conditioning system. But before he could speak, the air was punctuated by a chill-ing call from the engineer: “Engine failure number four. ” And within seconds the problems be-came worse: “Engine failure number two. Three’s gone . . . they’ve all gone. ” Captain Moody had practised all-engine failure a few months earlier but that related to a total failure of generators.
Now the crew was faced with a bewil-dering array of confusing dials and amber caution lights.
The crew quickly noticed a decay in air-speed and put the 747 into a slow descent.
Captain Moody told the first officer to issue a Mayday: “Jakarta, Jakarta, Mayday, Mayday Speedbird 9. We’ve lost all four engines. We’re leaving 370. ” However, it took some time for the full gravity of this message to get through as the static around the 747 was interfering with the radio transmissions.
Captain Moody recounts: “We had absolutely no idea what had happened. We had to think outside the box – it was so confusing. ” Relights were started on all the engines, even number four that had the fire handle pulled.
At 26,000ft the cabin pressurisation warning sounded and the crew donned their masks. However, the first officer’s fell apart in his hands, forcing Captain Moody into an emergency descent.
Continual attempts at restarts were terri-fying passengers as fuel ignited behind the engines by the St Elmo’s Fire danced over and around the wings, making it look as if the engines were on fire.
The 747’s INS was useless so some dead reckoning was used as they glided toward Jakarta.
As the 747 reached 14,000ft Captain Moody said he had begun to consider a water landing: “My father had taken me to Hythe Pier in Southampton to watch fly-ing boats land. I knew full well that flying boats did not fly at night because of the problem of judging distances. ” “I think we had another 10 minutes of glide left. My pondering was broken by the jubilation of the rest of the crew as number four started. ” Within 90 seconds, the other three engines had come back to life.
“Speedbird 9. We’re back in business. All four running, level at 12,000ft,” is how the news was announced to ATC.
With the numerous Indonesian volcanoes in mind Captain Moody requested a climb to 15,000ft, which was granted. “But then the St Elmo’s Fire returned and the number two began to surge,” he said. “I now thought that somehow the St Elmo’s Fire was con-nected with the engine problems. ” The number two engine was now shaking violently and with considerable reluctance he had it shut down: “I thought it would shake us apart. ” Still unsure of what was affecting the en-gines, he elected to use the aircraft’s flaps, speed brakes and undercarriage to control and slow the 747.
Speedbird 9 was cleared to Jakarta where the weather was fine and calm. But there was a complication, Captain Moody recounts: “We didn’t have glidepath information for Runway 24. We had great difficulty picking up the lights and what we didn’t realise is that the front windows were almost opaque from the ash. ” He says the final descent to touchdown was made “by using the localiser to stay on the centreline and by peering through the outer edge of the left hand front window, which was still clear. ” “I was just able to make out the VASIs on the left of the runway. The other crew members called out the DME distance and radio altitude to help me judge the descent. ” Interestingly, the crazing of the front windows became a diffused glare of bright light as the runway approached.
The landing was smooth and was greeted with thunderous applause and cheers from the passengers.
In the cockpit Captain Moody and the crew, now with time to survey their sur-roundings, discovered they were covered in fine black dust. Once outside they were stunned by what they saw.
“All the leading edges, engine nacelles and nose cone were stripped bare. We had been sandblasted,” he said. “The engines were the worst affected with significant damage to the turbine blades. ” The ash particles were . 075mm in diam-eter and the 747’s pitot tubes were filled with ash, which had given the crew varying airspeed readings.
But it was another day before they learned they had flown through Mt Galunggung, about 200km southeast of Jakarta.
“Jakarta, Jakarta, Mayday, Mayday Speedbird 9. We’ve lost all four engines. We’re leaving 370. ”
While the 747 was damaged, Brit-ish Airways’ reputation also was about to get blasted when the airline decided the traumatised passengers should be flown via Sydney to Perth. Captain Moody intervened and insisted on a dedicated 747 turning up to fly them onto Perth.
As a result of the ash encounter ICAO issued a special report in October 1984 on the dangers of volcanic ash to aircraft, advising crew to reduce thrust to zero, de-scend and leave the area as soon as possible.
“Consideration [should be given] to turning off the engines and restarting them when clear of the ash and inside the relight envelope,” the report said.
City of Edinburgh was later renamed City of Elgin and continued to fly for British Airways before being sold to European Aviation Air Charter. The 747 was with-drawn from service in February 2004 and scrapped in 2009.
When the Icelandic volcano Eyjafjalla-jökull erupted in 2010 Captain Moody was again a celebrity.
with Captain Eric Moody reminisce about flight through volcanic ash over Timor Sea. (Daily News via West
Australian Newspapers Ltd)
Reflecting on the incredible events of 1982, he muses that “when I learned to fly in the 50s, flying was dangerous and sex was safe. When I retired in the 90s that had gone the other way around. ” Captain Moody obviously has not lost his sense of humour but on a more sober-ing note he wonders how he would have – or could he have – dealt with the situation in a glass cockpit aircraft.
“We were in total control of a very dif-ficult situation. I would not have wanted to do that again in a 747-400 or any glass cockpit plane. ” Fast forward from the Eyjafjallajökull eruption to March this year – after two years of discussions ICAO issued a manual for decision-making in the event of a vol-canic eruption.
Entitled Flight Safety and Volcanic Ash, the manual provides guidance countries may recommend to aircraft operators when there is forecast volcanic ash contamina-tion, placing the responsibility for such operations on the operator under the over-sight of the state regulatory authority.
The manual is based mainly on the work of the ICAO International Volcanic Ash Task Force, set up by the organisation and the aviation community following the Eyjafjallajökull eruptions, which caused enormous disruption to air travel across and to and from western and northern Europe.
Secretary-General of ICAO Raymond Benjamin said: “The impact on air travel of the Eyjafjallajökull eruption was unprec-edented. It forced us to align our guidance material with the latest technological and scientific developments.
“The new approach, while ensuring the safety of flight operations, provides more flexibility and recommends that the decision to operate a flight in airspace containing volcanic ash rest with airlines, under the supervision of state regulatory authorities. ” Perhaps not surprisingly, the ash cloud encounters as outlined by the ICAO special publication are a mirror of Captain Moody’s terrifying experience. The report states: “Odour: when encountering volcanic ash, flightcrews usually notice a smoky or acrid odour that can smell like electrical smoke, burned dust or sulphur.
“Haze: most flightcrews, as well as cabin crew or passengers, see a haze develop within the aircraft cockpit and/or cabin. Dust can settle on surfaces.
“Engine: changing engine conditions. Surging, torching from the tailpipe and flameouts can occur. Engine temperatures can change unexpectedly and a white glow can appear at the engine inlet.
“Airspeed: if volcanic ash fouls the pitot tube, the indicated airspeed can decrease or fluctuate erratically.
“Pressurisation: cabin pressure can change, including possible loss of cabin pressurisation.
“Static discharges: a phenomenon similar to St Elmo’s Fire or glow can occur. In these instances, blue-coloured sparks can appear to flow up the outside of the windshield or a white glow can appear at the leading edges of the wings or at the front of the engine inlets. Any of these indicators should suffice to alert the flightcrew of an ash encounter and appropriate action should be taken to vacate the contaminated airspace as safely and expeditiously as possible. ” The UK’s Met Office’s Doug Johnson, reflecting in Airport World, the journal of Airport Council International, on the lessons learnt from the volcanic ash cloud crisis that closed most of Europe’s airports in 2010, said: “The impact of the Eyjafjal-lajökull volcanic eruption in April 2010 caused an unparalleled crisis in European aviation . . .
“ . . . movements through the airspace of 23 European countries stopped and restric-tions were in place in two others with over 300 airports, representing 75 per cent of the European network, closed. ” Eurocontrol estimated that more than 100,000 flights were cancelled, ruining the travel plans of 10 million passengers, many of whom were stranded for several days and had to find other ways to get to their des-tinations. In Australia, the domino affect meant that many travellers were stranded for weeks.
Mr Johnson said: “The airlines estimated their losses to be in the region of €1. 4 bil-lion, the airports €250 million, ground han-dlers €200 million and air navigation service providers €175 million with wider impacts on European economies beyond this. ” As a result, the EU and Eurocontrol established the European Aviation Crisis Co-ordination Cell and through the Inter-national Volcanic Ash Task Force there was a rethink of the standards and recommended procedures (SARPs) to guide the regulated regime used during volcanic ash events.
As a result of the BA9 incident and a similar event involving KLM Flight 867 in 1989, ICAO has established nine regulated Volcanic Ash Advisory Centres (VAACs) around the world to give advice to the avia-tion community on the advection [horizon-tal flow of air] and dispersion of ash clouds when a volcano erupts.
According to Mr Johnson: “Since 2002, the International Airways Volcano Watch Operations Group (IAVWOPSG) has been in operation to give guidance on volcanic ash avoidance, monitoring and dispersion.
“It advises ICAO what SARPs need to be included in Annex 3 to the Chicago Convention, which stipulates what mete-orological services (including advice about volcanic ash dispersion) should be provided for international air travel.
“VAACs are responsible for issuing volcanic ash advisories to state flight infor-mation centres and Meteorological Watch Offices (MWOs), which are normally run by the state’s national met service.
“The MWO then has the responsibil-ity for producing volcanic ash significant meteorological information (SIGMETs) for that state’s Flight Information Re-gions (FIRs) and then it is up to the state’s aviation authorities to decide whether the aviation community is further informed through NOTAMs or ASHTAMs. ” But he points out: “In November 2004 the European system established to follow this process was found wanting when the London VAAC provided advisories of an eruption of Grímsvötn that lasted a few days and spread a narrow plume of volcanic ash over parts of Scandinavia and eastern Europe.
“Many of the SIGMETs and NOTAMs that should have been produced did not appear and as a result ICAO and Eurocon-trol put together a task force to produce a European and North Atlantic Contingency Plan for Volcanic Ash.
“This was eventually implemented in 2006 and one of the components of the contingency plan was that the process should be tested by running exercises every six months – since then, these have been carried out to ensure that all stakeholders are familiar with the process in the event of a real eruption. ” So according to Mr Johnson, the London VAAC, ICAO and Eurocontrol were rela-tively content in April 2010 that Europe could handle anything that an Icelandic volcano could throw at them.
However, what the industry was not pre-pared for was Eyjafjallajökull, an eruption that would last for 39 days and where the ash was emitted into a stable meteorologi-cal situation that allowed it to stay in the atmosphere for an extended period – five to 10 days – without being washed out over Europe and the North Atlantic, some of the highest capacity airspaces in the world.
this year. (Guy Magowan/The West Australian)
Added to that, says Mr Johnson, was “the impact of the IAVWOPSG’s lack of success over the previous 10 years in establishing from the engine and airframe manufacturers a quantitative ash mass concentration that was safe for commercial jet engines to fly through”.
This was later established by the British CAA at a concentration of 0. 002 grams per cubic metre at regular cruise altitudes. Any airspace with a greater ash concentration is a no-fly zone. However, the interpretation is far from clear.
Ironically, only a day before Chile’s Puyehue-Cordon Caulle volcano erupted on June 4 last year, aeronautical chief of the World Meteorological Organization Dr Herbert Puempel warned in a paper that ash and aviation was a complex issue still under debate.
Dr Puempel warned that the industry was reluctant to set a limit because once it was agreed on, “lawyers would have a field day”.
President of the European Volcanologi-cal Society Henry Gaudru said scientists were unable to measure ash density in the atmosphere reliably, except in the immedi-ate vicinity of an eruption.
Confusing matters in the Australian and New Zealand context, local experts had dif-fering views in 2011 over the impact of the ash cloud from Chile.
And Dr Puempel warns that many volcanoes are poorly or not monitored. In a presentation last year, he called for more in-tegration of monitoring systems, to include space-based remote sensing systems and light detection and ranging for layer thick-ness and position.
He warned that ash tolerance is a highly complex issue with evidence from disman-tled aircraft engines pointing to the pos-sible role of acids such as sulphuric, HCI and fluorides.
Nonetheless, much is being done around the globe to mitigate the impact of vol-canic ash.
At the third Volcanic Ash Scientific Ad-visory Group in New Orleans in January a significant amount of activity on detection equipment and processes around the globe was reported.
European institutions also have been very active. There is an airborne forward-pointing infrared volcanic ash detection system – AVOID – which has been tested near Sicily’s Mount Etna, with more tests planned with a dedicated Airbus A340 test aircraft in Chile.
Easyjet is planning to put a system onboard an A320 for its Luton-Rejkjavik route. But the meeting warned about the “springing up of many, not always quality controlled ‘instant products’ by third-party vendors”.
What is clear on the 30th anniversary of BA9 is that the volcanic eruptions of 2010 and 2011 finally have galvanised the industry to increase the focus on volcanic ash detection significantly. n Some material in this article was taken with permission from an article published in BALPA magazine The Log in April 1986 by Captain Jack Diamond, a colleague of Captain Moody.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Australian Aviation a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Australian Aviation as a preferred news source.